Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Annuities 2: Fixed, Indexed, Variable (Read the Fine Print)

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: Many different products are called annuities. Some are simple, and some have layered costs. Know what it costs, what is guaranteed and how to leave before you sign.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: Many different products are called annuities. Some are simple, and some have layered costs. Know what it costs, what is guaranteed and how to leave before you sign.

The story: Gus meets three annuities

Gus sits at a desk across from Dana, who sells annuities, while a contract, charts and a price tag show how three kinds of annuity grow money and cost money.

  1. Narrator: Gus has $100,000 to set aside for later. Dana sells annuities. An annuity is a contract with an insurance company, a company paid to cover a risk.
  2. Narrator: You pay the company, your money grows, and later it pays you income. Dana shows Gus three kinds: fixed, indexed and variable.
  3. Dana: This fixed annuity pays 5% a year in interest, the money paid for using your money. The company sets the rate.
  4. Narrator: 5% of $100,000 is $5,000. So in one year, Gus’s $100,000 would grow to $105,000.
  5. Narrator: An indexed annuity adds interest based on an index, a number that follows the stock market. If the index falls, Gus gets 0%: no gain, and no loss.
  6. Narrator: But there is a cap, the most interest it can add. If Gus’s cap is 5% and the index rises 10%, Gus gets only 5%, which is $5,000.
  7. Narrator: A variable annuity puts money in funds, which pool many people’s money to buy many investments. If the funds fall 10%, Gus loses 10% of $100,000: $10,000.
  8. Narrator: Every kind has costs. Fees are charges taken out of your money. This variable annuity’s fees are 2% a year, and 2% of $100,000 is $2,000.
  9. Narrator: Leaving early can cost a surrender charge, a fee for taking money out early. A free look, usually 10 to 30 days, lets you cancel after the contract arrives.
  10. Gus: Then before I sign, I will ask what it costs each year, what is guaranteed and how you are paid.

What you’ll learn

  1. An annuity, and the fixed kind

    An annuity is a contract with an insurance company. In a deferred annuity, you pay in now, your money grows, and income starts later. Tax-deferred means no tax until you take money out. A fixed annuity guarantees at least a minimum interest rate. The company sets the rate.

    Lou puts $40,000 in a fixed annuity that pays 5% this year. 5% of $40,000 is $2,000, so after one year Lou has $42,000.

  2. Indexed: protected, but capped

    An indexed annuity is credited interest, meaning interest is added, based on an index, a number that follows the stock market. You do not know the rate ahead of time. It is never less than 0%, even if the market falls. A cap limits the most you can be credited. That limit is the price of the protection.

    Mia puts $30,000 in an indexed annuity with a cap of 4%. The index rises 8%. 1% of $30,000 is $300, so 4% is $1,200. Mia is credited $1,200. If the index falls 8%, Mia gets $0.

  3. Variable: funds and layered fees

    A variable annuity puts your money in funds, which pool many people’s money to buy many investments. Gains and losses have no limit. Fees come in layers: a fee for the contract, the funds’ own fees, and extra fees for any optional benefit, an added feature. Each layer takes a share every year.

    Raj puts $60,000 in funds. They rise 10%, which is $6,000. Fees are 2%, which is $1,200. Raj gains $6,000 minus $1,200, which is $4,800.

  4. Leaving early, and what to ask

    A surrender charge is a fee for taking money out within a set number of years. It usually shrinks over time. A free look is a short window to cancel, usually 10 to 30 days. Ask: the yearly cost, the surrender schedule, what is guaranteed and by whom, and how the seller is paid.

    Eve’s surrender charge in year one is 7%. Eve takes out $20,000. 1% of $20,000 is $200, so 7% is $1,400. Eve gets $18,600.

Key words

surrender charge
a fee for taking money out early
cap
the most an indexed annuity can credit you
optional benefit
an added feature that has its own fee
free look
a short window to cancel after the contract arrives

Common questions

Can an index-linked annuity lose money?
The fixed indexed kind in this lesson generally does not, except for a surrender charge. A registered index-linked annuity can. Its credited interest can be negative if the index does poorly, and the insurer may take money out of the contract. It usually limits both gains and losses. Ask for the exact limits in writing.
Is an optional income benefit worth it?
It depends. Some guaranteed benefits protect against an unlikely event, such as very large market losses, so you may pay for a benefit that never pays out. Ask what it costs, what is needed to keep it and how likely you are to use it.
What about an annuity inside an IRA?
Be careful. An IRA, an individual retirement account, already grows with no tax until money comes out, so an annuity adds no extra tax benefit there. The annuity is taxed like any other investment in the account. Ask how it fits your whole plan.
Should I swap my old annuity for a new one?
Compare the features, fees, rates and risks of both first. A new contract can start a new surrender charge period, and leaving the old one can cost a surrender charge. Some sellers earn more from a swap.

Remember this

Know what it costs and what is guaranteed before you sign.

Try it: Write the five questions

  1. Write these five questions on paper: the yearly cost, the surrender schedule, what is guaranteed and by whom, how the seller is paid, and how to get money out.
  2. If you’re looking at an annuity, ask for the answers in writing.
  3. Compare the answers with the contract before the free look ends.

No account needed: write the five questions on paper.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.