Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Pensions and Annuities: The Part You Already Paid Tax On

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: If you paid tax on money before it went into a pension or annuity, part of each check is that money coming back, and it is not taxed again.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: If you paid tax on money before it went into a pension or annuity, part of each check is that money coming back, and it is not taxed again.

The story: Orrin’s $21,000 of already-taxed money

Orrin sits at the kitchen table with pension papers and works out how much of each monthly check is tax-free.

  1. Narrator: Orrin is 67 and gets a pension, a monthly check from the old job. Income tax is the part of money coming in that the government collects.
  2. Narrator: Years ago, Orrin put $21,000 into the pension from pay that had already been taxed. That $21,000 is Orrin’s basis, money that was taxed once already.
  3. Orrin: When that $21,000 comes back to me inside my checks, do I pay tax on it a second time?
  4. Narrator: No. The IRS says you do not pay tax on the part of a payment that returns the after-tax money you paid in. The rest of the check is taxed as income.
  5. Narrator: For a pension from a job, the IRS Simplified Method spreads the basis evenly over a set number of checks. For one person aged 66 to 70, the table says 210.
  6. Narrator: $21,000 divided by 210 checks is $100 a check. So $100 of each check is tax-free. Orrin’s check is $800, so the other $700 is taxed.
  7. Narrator: 210 checks times $100 is $21,000. So after 210 checks, all of Orrin’s basis has come back, and from then on the whole check is taxed.
  8. Narrator: Orrin gets 12 checks a year. 12 times 17 is 204, and 6 more makes 210. So that takes 17 and a half years.
  9. Narrator: Orrin keeps old pay statements that show the $21,000 and gives the total to a tax preparer, the person who fills out the tax return.

What you’ll learn

  1. Money that was taxed before it went in

    A pension is a monthly check from a job. An annuity is a deal where you pay an insurance company and it pays you a set amount, often each month. Some pensions and annuities were paid for partly with money that was taxed before it went in. That amount is your basis. It is not taxed again.

    Rita paid $5,000 of already-taxed money into a pension. That $5,000 returns inside Rita’s checks, and the tax is not charged on it a second time.

  2. A pension from a job: the Simplified Method

    For most pensions from a job, the IRS Simplified Method divides your basis by a number of checks from an IRS table. The number depends on your age when checks start, and a pension that pays a couple uses both ages. The answer is the tax-free part of each check. The rest is taxed.

    Lena is 63, and Lena’s basis is $13,000. The table says 260 checks for one person aged 61 to 65. 260 times $50 is $13,000, so $50 of each check is tax-free.

  3. An annuity you bought yourself: the exclusion ratio

    For an annuity you bought with already-taxed savings, the tax-free share of each payment is the exclusion ratio. It is your basis divided by the expected return, the total the IRS tables say you will collect. The rest of each payment is taxed.

    Joel paid $30,000 for an annuity, and the IRS tables expect $60,000 in payments. $30,000 is half of $60,000, so half of each payment is tax-free: $200 of a $400 payment.

  4. Taking money out before payments start

    Some annuities you buy grow for years before payments start. To annuitize is to turn the money in it into regular payments. If you take money out before that, the growth, called earnings, comes out first and is taxed. Before age 59½, an extra 10% tax can apply too.

    Pia is 65 and paid $10,000 into an annuity now worth $14,000, so the growth is $4,000. Pia takes out $6,000. The $4,000 of growth comes out first and is taxed. The other $2,000 is not.

Key words

basis
money you already paid tax on before it went in
Simplified Method
the IRS way to spread a basis over a set number of pension checks
exclusion ratio
the tax-free share of each annuity payment
annuitize
turn a balance into regular payments

Common questions

What if I die before all my basis comes back?
The IRS says any basis not yet returned can be deducted on the final tax return of the person who dies. A deduction lowers the income that is taxed. A tax preparer can help with it.
What does “taxable amount not determined” on my 1099-R mean?
A 1099-R is the form that shows what a pension or annuity paid you. The IRS tells the payer to check that box when it cannot reasonably get the data needed to work out the taxable amount. Keep your basis papers and show them to a tax preparer.
Is the rule different for very old annuity contracts?
Yes. For a contract entered into before August 14, 1982, money put in before that date is an exception to the earnings-first rule. A tax preparer can check your papers.
Where is the Simplified Method worksheet?
It is in the instructions for the yearly federal tax return and in IRS Publication 575, Pension and Annuity Income. The IRS table of checks can change, so use the current one.

Remember this

Taxed before it went in? Do not pay it again coming out.

Try it: Find your already-taxed money

  1. Find old pay statements or plan papers that show money put in after tax.
  2. Write the total on a sheet of paper, with the plan or company name.
  3. If a pension or annuity pays you, give that total to your tax preparer.

Old pay statements or plan papers and a sheet of paper (no account needed).

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.