Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Pension Choice: Monthly Check or Lump Sum?

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: A pension lump sum trades a check for life for one big payment. Compare it with what an insurance company would charge for the same check.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: A pension lump sum trades a check for life for one big payment. Compare it with what an insurance company would charge for the same check.

The story: Walt’s big letter

Walt and Grace read a pension letter offering a monthly check for life or a lump sum, and weigh the two on a scale.

  1. Narrator: Walt is 65 and retiring after 30 years at one company. Walt earned a pension: a monthly check for life that the company promises its retired workers.
  2. Narrator: A letter offers a choice: $1,500 a month for life, or a lump sum, one big payment of $240,000 now.
  3. Walt: $240,000! That’s more money than I’ve ever seen in one place.
  4. Grace: If we spent $1,500 a month from it, $240,000 divided by $1,500 is 160 months. That’s about 13 years.
  5. Grace: Putting it in stocks, small pieces of companies, could make it last longer, but stocks can drop too. The monthly check lasts as long as you do, even to 100.
  6. Narrator: One fair test: ask an insurance company what it would charge for the same $1,500 check for life. Walt’s quote is $280,000.
  7. Narrator: $280,000 minus $240,000 is $40,000. So taking the lump sum would mean giving up a check that costs $40,000 more to buy back.
  8. Narrator: The lump sum does give control, and something to leave family. But if stocks drop, or Walt reaches 100, the risk of running out is Walt’s.
  9. Walt: So our health, our other income and how we’d handle a big sum all matter too.

What you’ll learn

  1. What the pension choice is

    A pension is a monthly check for life that an employer promises, earned by your years of work. Some plans offer a choice when you retire: the monthly check, or a lump sum, which is the whole value paid at once. Once you choose, you usually can’t switch.

  2. What each one protects

    The monthly check keeps coming for life, with no investing to do. But most pensions from private companies don’t rise when prices rise, so each check buys a little less over time. A lump sum gives you control and something to leave family. In return, the risk of a stock drop and of running out is yours.

    Say Walt spends $1,500 a month from $240,000, and it doesn’t grow. $240,000 divided by $1,500 is 160 months. That’s about 13 years.

  3. Interest rates change the offer

    Interest is what money earns while it sits saved. The plan figures the lump sum as the money that, set aside today and earning interest, would pay your checks. When interest rates are higher, less money is needed today, so the lump sum is smaller. When rates fall, it grows.

    To earn $500 a year in interest: at 5%, you need $10,000, since 5% of $10,000 is $500. At 10%, you need only $5,000.

  4. How to compare

    Ask an insurance company, or an online quote tool, what a lifetime check of the same size would cost. If that costs more than the lump sum, the monthly check is the better value. Taking the lump sum? A direct rollover into an IRA, a retirement account you own, keeps it from being taxed all at once.

    Walt’s lump sum is $240,000. The same check from an insurance company costs $280,000. $280,000 minus $240,000 is $40,000, so the monthly check is worth $40,000 more.

Key words

pension
a monthly check for life that an employer promises
Also called: defined benefit plan
lump sum
the whole value paid at once
interest rate
how much money earns in a year, as a percent
direct rollover
money sent straight from a plan into an IRA, so it isn’t taxed yet

Common questions

What is an IRA?
An individual retirement account: an account you own with special tax rules. In a traditional IRA, tax waits until you take money out.
I already took the lump sum. What still matters?
Plenty. A steady withdrawal plan, a mix of investments built to last decades, and knowing how much of your must-pay bills your savings cover all help. Later lessons on safe spending and stock market timing cover them.
Is my pension safe if the company fails?
Most private pensions are insured by the PBGC, a federal agency, up to limits. Public pensions follow state rules. PBGC.gov shows the limits.
I don’t have a pension. Is this lesson for me?
The ideas still help, but the lesson on income annuities, which are like a pension you buy, may fit you better.

Remember this

A lump sum is only a deal if you couldn’t buy the same check back for less.

Try it: Compare your pension offer

  1. Find your pension’s monthly amount and any lump-sum offer.
  2. Get a quote for a lifetime check of the same size from an insurance company or an online quote tool.
  3. Subtract the lump sum from the quote, and note your health and other income.

Without an account, write the lump sum and the quote side by side on paper.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Practice with real numbers:Try the retirement calculator

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.