Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free
Borrowing Against What You Own
- Warm-up
- Story
- Learn
- Play
- Quiz
- Remember
- Try it
- Finish
About this lesson
About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions
The big idea: Loans backed by things you own, like a 401(k), investments, a home or a life insurance policy, cost less than a card. But each costs something real, and the thing you own is what you risk.
Lesson outline
The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more
The big idea: Loans backed by things you own, like a 401(k), investments, a home or a life insurance policy, cost less than a card. But each costs something real, and the thing you own is what you risk.
The story: Nora needs a new roof
Nora needs $10,000 for a new roof and talks with a friend, Lee, about borrowing against a 401(k), investments, a home or a life insurance policy.
- Narrator: Nora needs $10,000 for a new roof. Nora has no spare cash, but owns a 401(k) retirement account, some investments, a home and a life insurance policy.
- Narrator: Each one can be collateral: something you own that backs a loan. If you don’t pay, the lender can take it. A lender is whoever lent the money.
- Lee: That’s why these loans charge less interest than a card. Interest is the price of borrowing. The lender worries less, because it can take what you own.
- Nora: My 401(k) is my retirement account at work. It offers a loan at 5%. 5% of $10,000 is $500 a year, and that interest goes back into my own account.
- Narrator: But while it’s out, the $10,000 leaves Nora’s investments, the funds in the account that can grow or fall.
- Narrator: If the funds grow 8% that year, the $10,000 misses 8% of $10,000, which is $800. Nora paid in $500, so $800 minus $500 leaves Nora $300 behind.
- Lee: And if you leave your job, you may have to pay back the rest soon. What isn’t paid back is taxed. It may also get a 10% penalty, an extra charge.
- Lee: Some people borrow at 5% to invest. If the investment earns 8%, 8% of $10,000 is $800. $800 minus $500 of interest leaves $300 extra.
- Narrator: But if the investment falls 20% instead, 20% of $10,000 is $2,000 gone. And the borrower still owes all $10,000, plus $500 of interest.
- Nora: So each loan is cheap until the thing I own is on the line. I’ll compare what each one risks, not just the rate.
What you’ll learn
Collateral: what you own backs the loan
Collateral is something you own that backs a loan. If you stop paying, the lender can take it. The lender is the bank or company that lent the money. It risks less, so the rate is usually lower than a card’s. The rate is the yearly price of borrowing as a percent. Interest is that price in dollars.
On a card at 25%, $10,000 costs a quarter of $10,000, which is $2,500 a year. Backed by something you own at 5%, it costs $500. That’s $2,000 less.
A 401(k) loan: you pay yourself, but miss growth
A 401(k) is a retirement account through work. Many plans let you borrow from it and repay from your paycheck. The interest goes into your own account. But the money leaves your investments while it’s out, so it misses any growth. If you leave the job, the rest may be due soon, or be taxed and get a penalty.
$10,000 out for a year at 5% pays $500 back to you. In an 8% year, it would have grown $800. $800 minus $500 leaves you $300 behind.
Investments or a home as collateral
A securities-backed loan uses your investments, like stocks and funds, as collateral. If prices drop too far, the lender can sell them cheap or demand more money, called a margin call. A home equity loan uses your home. Equity is the home’s value minus what you still owe. Miss payments, and you can lose the home.
$20,000 of investments backs a $10,000 loan. If prices fall by half, half of $20,000 is $10,000. Now they barely cover the loan, so the lender can sell them.
Life insurance loans and “be your own bank”
Some life insurance builds cash value, a savings part inside the policy. You can borrow against it, and the insurance company charges interest. Unpaid loans and interest shrink what your family gets. Some sellers call this “be your own bank.” These policies usually cost much more than plain coverage, so compare costs.
A $200,000 policy has a $10,000 loan and $500 of unpaid interest. $10,000 plus $500 is $10,500. $200,000 minus $10,500 leaves your family $189,500.
Key words
- collateral
- something you own that a lender can take or sell if you don’t pay
- securities-backed loan
- a loan that uses your investments as collateral
- margin call
- a lender’s demand for more money when the investments backing a loan fall
- cash value
- the savings part inside some life insurance policies
Common questions
- How much can I borrow from my 401(k)?
- The IRS is the tax agency. It sets a top limit, usually up to half of the money that’s fully yours in the account, with a dollar cap. Your plan can set lower limits. Most loans must be repaid within five years.
- When does the 10% penalty apply?
- Usually when money comes out of a retirement account before age 59½. There are exceptions, and the IRS lists them.
- Is a home equity loan the same as a home equity line of credit?
- No. A home equity loan pays you one lump sum at a fixed rate. A line of credit lets you borrow as you need it, usually at a rate that can change. The lesson on home equity walks through both.
- Is borrowing to invest ever reasonable?
- Some people do it, but the debt stays even when the investment falls. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau warns that no investment is risk-free, and borrowing against your home to invest puts the home at risk.
Remember this
Borrowing against what you own costs less, but what you own is at risk.
Try it: List what backs each loan
- List each loan you have, with its rate and what backs it, like a home or a 401(k).
- For each one, write down what happens if you leave your job or prices fall.
- Add each loan, with its rate, in Debts to see it next to everything else.
No account needed: a sheet of paper, or the sample household in the demo.
Live facts
Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.
401(k) loan limits, repayment and loan offsets
Source: IRS.gov(opens in a new tab)Securities-backed lines of credit and their risks
Source: FINRA.org(opens in a new tab)What a margin call is
Source: Investor.gov (SEC)(opens in a new tab)Home equity loans, and borrowing against your home to invest
Source: ConsumerFinance.gov(opens in a new tab)Policy loans, cash value and the death benefit
Source: NAIC(opens in a new tab)
Builds on
Leads to
Practice with real numbers:Compare loan payments at different rates
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.