Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Keep a Debt or Pay It Off?

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: Paying a debt early “earns” its interest rate. Compare that rate with what the money could earn elsewhere, after a safety net and any employer match.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: Paying a debt early “earns” its interest rate. Compare that rate with what the money could earn elsewhere, after a safety net and any employer match.

The story: Three jobs for one extra $100

Marcus compares paying extra on a 25% credit card, a 5% student loan, savings and a retirement account with an employer match, while a coworker, Lee, helps.

  1. Narrator: Marcus pays every bill and still has $100 extra each month. Marcus also has three debts. A debt is money you owe.
  2. Marcus: A student loan at 5% a year, a car loan at 5%, and a credit card at 25%. Where should the extra $100 go?
  3. Narrator: A debt’s rate is its yearly price, shown as a percent. Each dollar paid off early stops costing that rate.
  4. Narrator: 25% of $100 is $25. So $100 extra on the card saves $25 of interest in a year. On the 5% student loan, it saves just $5.
  5. Lee: Don’t forget the match at work. Our employer adds 50 cents to your retirement account for every dollar you put in, up to a limit.
  6. Narrator: That’s an employer match, money your job adds to your retirement savings. Put in $100, and $50 is added: 50% right away, double the card’s 25%.
  7. Marcus: But I have almost nothing saved. If my car breaks down, the repair goes on the card at 25%.
  8. Narrator: Money kept for surprise costs is an emergency fund. Many people build a small one first, so one surprise doesn’t undo their progress.
  9. Marcus: So: a small emergency fund, then the full match, then extra on the 25% card. The 5% loans keep getting their regular payments.
  10. Narrator: Here’s how many people decide: compare each debt’s rate with what the money could earn elsewhere. The bigger number usually gets the extra dollar.

What you’ll learn

  1. What paying early means

    A debt is money you owe. The lender is the bank or company you owe. It sets a minimum payment: the smallest amount due each month. Paying early means paying more than that. Each extra dollar shrinks the balance, which is the amount still owed. And that dollar stops costing interest at the debt’s rate.

    A card charges 25% a year. 25% of $100 is $25. So $100 extra on the card saves $25 of interest over a year.

  2. When keeping a debt can win

    A return is what money earns, as a percent of what you put in. Paying a debt early is like earning its rate, with no risk. If savings pay more than a debt charges, keeping the debt can come out ahead. A mortgage is a home loan. It often has a fixed rate that can’t change. Savings rates can drop.

    A home loan charges a fixed 2%, and savings pay 5%. 1% of $10,000 is $100. So paying $10,000 off early saves $200 a year. Saving it earns $500, before tax.

  3. Where the employer match fits

    An employer match is money your job adds to your retirement account when you put money in. A retirement account is savings for when you stop working. A 50% match is a 50% return right away, higher than almost any debt’s rate. But that money is for later life. Taking it out early usually costs taxes and a penalty.

    Put $100 in with a 50% match: the employer adds $50, so you have $150. The same $100 on a 25% card saves $25 in a year.

  4. A safety net first

    An emergency fund is money kept for surprise costs, like a car repair. Without one, a surprise bill often lands on a card at a high rate, and the progress is gone. So many people build a small emergency fund before extra debt payments, and keep making the regular payments on low-rate loans.

    Marcus pays $300 extra on the card, then the car needs a $300 repair. With no savings, the $300 goes right back on the card at 25%.

Key words

extra payment
money paid on a debt beyond the minimum
return
what money earns, as a percent of what you put in
fixed rate
a loan rate that stays the same for the whole loan

Common questions

Is a student loan “good debt”?
People use “good debt” for borrowing that builds something worth more than it costs, like a degree that raises pay or a car that gets you to work. It’s never guaranteed, so the rate and the amount still matter.
Do I keep the match if I leave my job?
Not always. Many plans make you stay a set time before the employer’s part is fully yours. That rule is called vesting, and the plan’s papers spell it out.

Remember this

Compare each debt’s rate with what the money could earn.

Try it: Give your extra $100 a job

  1. List each debt with its rate, or use Marcus’s three debts.
  2. Look up what a savings account pays, and whether your job offers a match.
  3. For each choice, work out what $100 saves or earns in a year.
  4. Check a payoff in the loan payoff calculator and note which choice comes out ahead.

Use Marcus’s debts from this lesson and the free loan payoff calculator.

Practice with real numbers:Try the loan payoff calculator

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.