Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Pay Off the Mortgage Early or Invest?

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: An extra mortgage payment earns your loan rate for sure. Savings or investing may earn more, but savings rates can drop and investments can fall, while a fixed loan rate stays put.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: An extra mortgage payment earns your loan rate for sure. Savings or investing may earn more, but savings rates can drop and investments can fall, while a fixed loan rate stays put.

The story: Two loans, one choice

Marcus and Ana, with a 6% mortgage, and their friend Lee, with a 2% mortgage, each decide whether extra cash should pay down the loan or go into savings.

  1. Narrator: Marcus and Ana have a mortgage at a 6% interest rate. A mortgage is a home loan. That rate is the yearly price of borrowing: 6 cents for each dollar owed.
  2. Narrator: Their friend Lee got a mortgage years ago at a fixed rate of 2%. Fixed means it can never change. Each household has $10,000 of extra cash.
  3. Marcus: If we pay $10,000 extra on our loan, we stop paying 6% on it. 6% of $10,000 is $600. So we keep $600 a year, for sure.
  4. Lee: My loan is only 2%. 2% of $10,000 is $200. But my savings account pays 5%. 5% of $10,000 is $500.
  5. Narrator: But interest you earn is taxed, like pay from a job. Say a quarter of it goes to tax. A quarter of $500 is $125, so Lee keeps $375.
  6. Narrator: $375 minus $200 is $175. For now, savings come out $175 ahead for Lee. But savings rates can drop. A fixed loan rate can’t go up.
  7. Narrator: If Lee’s savings rate falls to 2%, the account earns $200. After a quarter goes to tax, that’s $150, less than the $200 the loan costs.
  8. Ana: For us, 5% savings wouldn’t win. We’d keep $375, and our loan costs $600. Stocks might earn more, but not for sure. Stocks are small pieces of companies.
  9. Ana: First, we’ll get the full match. That’s money a job adds when we save. Then we’ll fill our emergency fund. Money paid into a house is hard to get back.
  10. Marcus: After that, we compare what each choice keeps for us, and pick the trade-off we like better.

What you’ll learn

  1. Paying extra is a sure return

    A return is what your money earns for you. Every extra dollar you pay on a mortgage stops being charged interest. So on a 6% loan, an extra dollar is like earning 6% a year, for sure. That’s a guaranteed return. Your monthly payment stays the same, but the loan ends sooner.

    Pay $10,000 extra on a 6% loan. 6% of $10,000 is $600, so you skip $600 of interest in the first year.

  2. Compare it with savings, after tax

    A savings account pays interest too. But the interest you earn is taxed like pay, while interest you avoid on a loan isn’t. So compare what you keep after tax with what the loan charges. When the loan rate is higher, paying it down usually wins.

    $10,000 at 5% earns $500. If a quarter goes to tax, that’s $125, so you keep $375. A 6% loan costs $600. $600 is more, so paying the loan wins.

  3. When the loan rate is low

    Some people have a low fixed rate, like 2%. If savings pay more, keeping the cash can earn more than paying the loan down. But savings rates change and can drop, while the fixed loan rate stays put. Keep checking the rate, and check that the bank is insured.

    $10,000 at 5%, less a quarter for tax, keeps $375. A 2% loan costs $200. But if savings fall to 2%, you keep $150, less than $200.

  4. Investing: maybe more, not promised

    Stock funds own small pieces of many companies. They may grow faster than a loan rate over many years. They can also fall, sometimes for years. Money paid into a house is hard to reach unless you sell or borrow. Cover the basics first: the full employer match, high-rate debt and an emergency fund.

Key words

return
what your money earns for you
guaranteed return
a gain you know you’ll get, like the interest an extra payment saves
fixed rate
an interest rate that can never change for the life of the loan

Common questions

Is savings interest really taxed?
Yes. Interest from savings accounts and CDs counts as income on your tax return. How much goes to tax depends on your income and your state.
Does the mortgage interest deduction change this?
Only if you itemize, which means listing your deductions one by one on your taxes. Many people take the standard deduction instead. If you do itemize, the deduction lowers your real loan cost a little, so the number to beat is a bit lower.
So which one is right?
Neither is right for everyone. It depends on your rates, how much risk you’re comfortable with, how soon you might need the money and how you feel about owing. Some people do a bit of each.

Remember this

Extra payments earn your loan rate for sure. Savings or investing might beat it.

Try it: Run both paths

  1. Find your mortgage rate and whether it’s fixed, and your savings account’s rate.
  2. For $10,000 of extra cash, or your own amount, work out what paying the loan saves and what savings keep after tax.
  3. In the Loan Payoff Calculator, add an extra monthly payment and note the interest saved.

No account needed: work it out on paper and with the free Loan Payoff Calculator, or try the sample household in the demo.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Practice with real numbers:Try an extra payment in the loan payoff calculator

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.