Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Tax Now or Tax Later: Traditional vs Roth

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: Traditional skips the tax now and taxes the money later. Roth taxes it now and can pay out tax-free later. Having some of each keeps your choices open.

Lesson outline

The big idea: Traditional skips the tax now and taxes the money later. Roth taxes it now and can pay out tax-free later. Having some of each keeps your choices open.

The story: Ana picks a bucket

At work, Ana and a coworker, Lee, talk through a scale with “tax now” on one side and “tax later” on the other.

  1. Narrator: A 401(k) is a retirement account at work, filled from each paycheck. Ana’s asks a new question: traditional or Roth? Ana asks a coworker, Lee.
  2. Ana: What’s the difference? It’s the same money either way.
  3. Lee: Income tax is the tax on money you earn. It’s about when you pay it. Traditional skips the tax now. You pay it later, when you take the money out.
  4. Lee: Roth is the other way around. You pay the tax now, and if you follow the rules, the money comes out tax-free later.
  5. Narrator: Say Ana puts in $100 of pay, and it doubles to $200 by retirement. Ana’s tax rate is the percent that goes to tax. It’s 20% now.
  6. Narrator: With Roth, 20% of $100 is $20 of tax now, so $80 goes in. It doubles to $160 and all of it comes out tax-free.
  7. Narrator: With traditional, the whole $100 goes in and doubles to $200. If the rate later is 10%, the tax is $20 and Ana keeps $180.
  8. Ana: And if my rate later is still 20%, the tax is $40. $200 minus $40 is $160, the same as Roth.
  9. Lee: Right, but nobody knows future tax rules. So I split mine: some traditional, some Roth. Later I can choose which to take from.
  10. Ana: These are my best-paying years, so my rate is probably higher now. I’ll put most in traditional, and some in Roth.

What you’ll learn

  1. Same account, two tax choices

    Income tax is the tax you pay on money you earn. An IRA is a retirement account you open yourself. Many 401(k)s and IRAs come in two kinds: traditional and Roth. The same investments grow the same way in both. The only difference is when you pay income tax: now, or later when you take the money out.

  2. How each one works

    Traditional money goes in before income tax, so your tax bill this year is smaller. In retirement, what you take out is taxed as income. Roth money goes in after tax, so there’s no break today. In retirement, it comes out tax-free if you meet two rules: an age rule and a five-year rule.

    $100 of pay with a 20% tax rate. Traditional puts in all $100 and pays the tax later. Roth pays 20% of $100, which is $20, now and puts in $80.

  3. Your rate now and your rate later

    Your tax rate is the percent taken in tax from your top dollars of pay. If it’s higher now than it will be in retirement, traditional tends to leave more. If it’s lower now, Roth tends to. If it stays the same, they come out even. Best-paying years often favor traditional. Lower-pay years often favor Roth.

    $100 doubles. Roth at 20% now: $80 grows to $160. Traditional at 10% later: $200 minus $20 is $180. At 20% later, both leave $160.

  4. Three tax buckets

    Traditional money, Roth money and a regular investment account with no tax break are three tax buckets, each taxed a different way. No one knows future tax rates. So having some money in each lets you choose, year by year in retirement, which one to take from.

Key words

traditional
saved before income tax, so it’s taxed when it comes out
Also called: pre-tax
Roth
saved after tax, so it can come out tax-free later if you follow the rules
tax rate
the percent taken in tax from your top dollars of pay
tax bucket
a group of accounts taxed the same way

Common questions

What are the Roth rules exactly?
For growth to come out tax-free, you usually need to be at least 59½ and the account must have been open at least five years. The money you put into a Roth IRA yourself, not its growth, can come out anytime without tax.
Can I have both a Roth and a traditional account?
Yes. Many people save in both, in a workplace plan, an IRA or both. The yearly limit is shared, not doubled: $7,500 across all your IRAs.
Does the employer match go in as Roth?
Often the match goes in as traditional money even when you pick Roth. Some plans let it go in as Roth. Your plan summary says which.
Does a Roth account grow faster?
No. The same investments grow the same way in either one. The difference is only when the tax is paid.

Remember this

Pay tax when your rate is lower, and keep some in each bucket.

Try it: Label your buckets

  1. List each retirement account you have.
  2. Find out whether each one is traditional or Roth. Your statements usually say.
  3. Note roughly how much sits in each bucket: traditional, Roth and regular investing.

No account needed: your account statements and a sheet of paper.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.