Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free
Roth or Traditional? Tax Now or Later
- Warm-up
- Story
- Learn
- Play
- Quiz
- Remember
- Try it
- Finish
About this lesson
About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions
The big idea: Traditional skips the income tax now and taxes the money when it comes out. Roth takes the tax now, and the money comes out tax-free later. Pay the tax when your rate is lower.
Lesson outline
The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more
The big idea: Traditional skips the income tax now and taxes the money when it comes out. Roth takes the tax now, and the money comes out tax-free later. Pay the tax when your rate is lower.
The story: Two coworkers, two choices
Ana and Marcus fill out a workplace retirement form that asks them to choose traditional or Roth, then work out the tax on $100 with a balance scale between them.
- Narrator: Ana and Marcus just started new jobs. Both signed up for the 401(k), a retirement account you get through work.
- Narrator: Retirement is the time after you stop working. The money in the account is invested: put into things like company shares that can grow for years.
- Ana: The form asks one more thing: traditional or Roth. What’s the difference?
- Marcus: It’s about income tax, the part of your pay that goes to the government. Traditional skips that tax now. You pay it later, when you take the money out.
- Ana: And Roth is the other way around. I pay the tax now, and later the money comes out tax-free.
- Narrator: Say the tax rate is 20%, so 20 cents of every dollar goes to tax. And say $100 of pay goes in and doubles over the years.
- Narrator: Roth first. 20% of $100 is $20, paid in tax now. So $80 goes in. It doubles to $160, and all $160 comes out tax-free.
- Narrator: Now traditional. All $100 goes in and doubles to $200. Then the tax: 20% of $200 is $40. $200 minus $40 leaves $160.
- Marcus: The same $160! So when the tax rate is the same, they come out even. What matters is whether your rate is lower now or later.
- Ana: I’m just starting out, so my pay and my tax rate are low now. And if I’m not sure, the plan lets me split my money between the two.
What you’ll learn
One choice: when you pay the tax
A retirement account holds money for the years after you stop working, invested so it can grow. Many come in two kinds. In a traditional account, money goes in before income tax and is taxed when it comes out. In a Roth account, money goes in after tax and comes out tax-free later, if you follow the rules.
$100 of pay, and a 20% tax rate. Traditional puts all $100 in now. Roth takes 20% of $100, which is $20, for tax first. So $80 goes in.
Same tax rate, same result
If your tax rate is the same now and later, both kinds leave you the same money. Taking 20% at the start or 20% at the end takes the same share. So the choice only matters when your tax rate changes between now and when you take the money out.
The $100 doubles. Roth: $80 grows to $160, tax-free. Traditional: $100 grows to $200, then 20% of $200 is $40 in tax. $200 minus $40 is $160.
When your rate changes
More pay usually means a higher tax rate on your top dollars, called your marginal rate. The better deal is paying the tax when your rate is lower. Lower now, as it is for many people early in a career, points to Roth. Lower later points to traditional.
10% now, 25% later, and $100 doubles. Roth: 10% of $100 is $10, so $90 grows to $180. Traditional: $100 grows to $200, and 25% of $200 is $50, leaving $150.
Not sure? Split it
Nobody knows future tax rates for sure. Many workplace plans let you send part of each paycheck to Roth and part to traditional. Then some of your money gets the better deal either way, so you don’t have to guess right. Most plans let you change the split later.
Key words
- traditional
- a retirement account you put money in before tax; it’s taxed when it comes out
- Roth
- a retirement account you put money in after tax; it comes out tax-free if you follow the rules
- marginal rate
- the tax rate on your top dollars of pay
- qualified withdrawal
- a Roth withdrawal that follows the rules, so it’s tax-free
Common questions
- Does the employer match go in as Roth?
- The match is the money your job adds. It often goes in as traditional money, even when you pick Roth. Some plans let it go in as Roth. The plan’s summary says which.
- Can I change my choice later?
- Yes. Most plans let you change the split for future paychecks at any time.
- Are there other Roth rules?
- Yes. A Roth IRA is one you open yourself. It has income limits: above a certain income, you can’t put money in directly. Your own deposits can come out anytime, but the growth comes out tax-free only after age 59½, with the account open at least 5 years.
Remember this
Roth: pay tax now. Traditional: pay tax later. Not sure? Split it.
Try it: Weigh the choice with your own tax rate
- Find your marginal tax rate, using the lesson How Income Tax Really Works.
- Guess whether your rate later will be higher, lower or about the same.
- Note which choice that points to, or whether a split fits.
Look up your rate in the lesson How Income Tax Really Works, then compare it with what you expect later.
Live facts
Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.
IRA yearly limit
$7,500
Total you can put into all your IRAs (traditional and Roth) in a year, if you have that much earned income
As of 2026
Source: IRS.gov(opens in a new tab)Roth IRA income limits and withdrawal rules
Source: IRS.gov(opens in a new tab)Roth vs traditional workplace accounts compared
Source: IRS.gov(opens in a new tab)
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.