Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free
High-Earner Extras: Deferred Pay, After-Tax 401(k) and Stock Options
- Warm-up
- Story
- Learn
- Play
- Quiz
- Remember
- Try it
- Finish
About this lesson
About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions
The big idea: Some higher-paying jobs offer extra ways to save or get paid. Each one has a catch to understand before you use it.
Lesson outline
The big idea: Some higher-paying jobs offer extra ways to save or get paid. Each one has a catch to understand before you use it.
The story: Dana reads three offers
Dana sits at a desk in an office and weighs three extras the employer offers, finding the catch in each one before deciding.
- Narrator: Dana earns $200,000 a year. Dana’s employer, the company Dana works for, offers three extras. Each has a catch, a downside to understand first.
- Narrator: Extra one is deferred pay, pay put off until later. The employer holds $20,000 of Dana’s pay and promises to pay it in 5 years.
- Dana: The upside is that income tax on it usually waits until it is paid. But where is that $20,000 until then? It stays the company’s money.
- Narrator: It is only a promise. If the company can’t pay its debts, Dana is just one of many people it owes, so Dana might not be paid. The date is also hard to change.
- Narrator: Extra two is after-tax money in the 401(k), a retirement account through work. Taxes are money the government takes. This money goes in after taxes come out.
- Narrator: Dana could then move it to a Roth account, where money taken out in retirement is usually not taxed, growth included. But the plan has to allow both steps.
- Narrator: Extra three is incentive stock options: the right to buy shares, small pieces of the company, at $10 each. For 1,000 shares, 1,000 times $10 is $10,000.
- Narrator: Buying is called exercising. Regular income tax is usually not due then. But the alternative minimum tax, a second way of figuring tax, may be.
- Dana: First, the basics: the full match the company adds when I save, an emergency fund of savings for surprises, and no high-interest debt like card debt.
- Narrator: For choices this big, a tax professional can check the rules for Dana’s own case.
What you’ll learn
Deferred pay: a promise for later
Deferred compensation means the employer holds back part of your pay and promises to pay it later. Income tax on it usually waits until then. But until it is paid, it is still the company’s money. If the company can’t pay its debts, you might not be paid. The payment date can change only in limited ways.
Kim’s employer holds $15,000 of Kim’s pay and promises it in 4 years. If the company can’t pay its debts, Kim is one of the people it owes, so Kim might not be paid.
After-tax money in a 401(k)
An after-tax contribution is money you put into a retirement account after taxes were already taken out of it. Some plans allow it, and some let you move it to a Roth account, where money taken out in retirement is usually not taxed. The plan’s administrator, the company that runs it, can say what is allowed.
Rae puts $10,000 of after-tax money in and it earns $500. The $500 is pretax money, money not taxed yet, so moving it into a Roth is taxed as income. The $10,000 was taxed already.
Stock options and the second tax
An incentive stock option is the right to buy company shares at a set price. Using it is called exercising. Regular income tax is usually not due then, but the alternative minimum tax may be. That is a second way of figuring tax. You pay the extra only if that way comes out higher than regular tax.
Jo can buy 100 shares at $20 that now sell for $50. For the second tax, the IRS counts the difference: $50 minus $20 is $30 a share, and 100 times $30 is $3,000.
Basics first, then get help
Many people cover the basics before any extra: the full match, which is money the job adds when you save, an emergency fund, which is savings for surprises, and no high-interest debt, like credit card debt. For choices like these, a tax professional can check the rules for your own case.
Before looking at an extra, Lena checks three things: the full match, an emergency fund, and no high-interest debt. If one is missing, Lena starts there.
Key words
- deferred compensation
- pay the employer holds back and promises to pay later
- after-tax contribution
- money put into a retirement account after taxes were already taken out of it
- incentive stock option
- the right to buy company shares at a set price
- alternative minimum tax
- a second way of figuring tax for high incomes; you owe it only if it comes out higher
Common questions
- Is a “mega backdoor Roth” the same as after-tax money?
- People sometimes use that nickname for putting after-tax money in a 401(k) and moving it to a Roth. It works only if the plan allows both steps, and the earnings are taxed as income when moved. How much fits depends on the plan.
- Where can I check the rules?
- The IRS explains them on its pages for stock options, after-tax rollovers, Roth accounts and the alternative minimum tax. Rules can change, so a tax professional can check your own case.
Remember this
Every extra comes with a catch. Find it before you sign up.
Try it: Find the catch in each extra
- List any extras your job offers: deferred pay, after-tax 401(k) money or stock options.
- For each one, write its catch in one sentence.
- If you have a deferred pay balance, add it in Assets as its own line, with the payout date in the notes.
Write the list on paper, or use the public Net Worth Calculator to add a deferred pay balance as its own line.
Live facts
Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.
Deferred pay is the employer’s unsecured promise to pay, open to the employer’s creditors; income tax is deferred; the payment date can change only in limited ways
Source: IRS Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Audit Technique Guide(opens in a new tab)Incentive stock options: no regular income tax at exercise, but alternative minimum tax may apply that year
Source: IRS Topic no. 427(opens in a new tab)For the alternative minimum tax, exercising an incentive stock option counts the share value minus the price paid
Source: IRS Instructions for Form 6251(opens in a new tab)What the alternative minimum tax is and when it is owed
Source: IRS Topic no. 556(opens in a new tab)Earnings on after-tax contributions are pretax amounts
Source: IRS rollovers of after-tax contributions(opens in a new tab)Qualified Roth distributions, earnings included, are not taxed; a plan can allow in-plan Roth rollovers, which usually create taxable income
Source: IRS Designated Roth account(opens in a new tab)
Builds on
Leads to
Practice with real numbers:Try the net worth calculator
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.