Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Consolidation and Balance Transfers: Tool or Trap?

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: Moving debt can lower the interest you pay, but it only works if you stop adding new debt.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: Moving debt can lower the interest you pay, but it only works if you stop adding new debt.

The story: Sol moves a balance

Sol compares an old credit card with a new offer, works out the fee and the end date of the low rate, and sees why charging the old card again undoes the plan.

  1. Narrator: Sol owes $4,000 on a credit card, a card that lets you buy now and pay later. Its rate is 25%. A rate is the yearly price of borrowing.
  2. Narrator: A new card offers a balance transfer: moving what you owe on one card to another card. Its rate is 0% for 12 months.
  3. Narrator: A low rate for a limited time is called a promotional APR. The new card also charges a transfer fee, a charge for moving the balance, the amount owed.
  4. Narrator: The fee is 5%. 10% of $4,000 is $400, so 5% is half of that, $200. Sol would owe $4,000 plus $200, which is $4,200.
  5. Narrator: Sol pays $350 a month. 12 times $350 is $4,200. So after 12 months the new card is paid off, and no interest, the price of borrowing, was added.
  6. Narrator: On the old card, 25% a year is about 2% a month. 2% of $4,000 is $80, so about $80 of the first $350 would pay interest. After 12 payments, Sol would still owe.
  7. Narrator: But the low rate ends after 12 months, and the rate can then go up. If money is still owed, it starts costing more. So the end date matters.
  8. Narrator: Now the old card shows $0 owed, so Sol could use it again. Say Sol charges $1,200 on it. Then Sol owes $4,200 plus $1,200, which is $5,400.
  9. Sol: The transfer moved my debt. It did not remove it. Not adding new debt is what removes it.
  10. Narrator: Some companies offer to get debts lowered for a fee. An FTC rule says many that sell this by phone can’t charge until at least one debt is lowered.

What you’ll learn

  1. Moving a balance to a new card

    A balance transfer moves what you owe, your balance, from one card to another. A promotional APR is a low yearly rate for a limited time. A transfer fee is a charge for the move, usually a percent of the amount or a set dollar amount, whichever is more. After the time ends, the rate can rise.

    A $3,000 balance moves to a card with a 3% fee and 0% for 6 months. 1% of $3,000 is $30, so 3% is $90. The new card starts with $3,090 owed.

  2. One loan for many debts

    A loan is money you borrow and pay back. A consolidation loan is a new loan used to pay off several debts, so you make one payment instead of many. A lower monthly payment can mean more months of payments, and a larger total.

    Pat can pay $400 a month for 5 months: 5 times $400 is $2,000. Or $250 a month for 10 months: 10 times $250 is $2,500. The lower payment costs $500 more.

  3. Compare the whole cost

    To compare choices, add up everything you would pay for each: the fees plus the interest, which is the price of borrowing. Then check the date you would be done. The choice with the lowest monthly payment is not always the one with the lowest total.

    Choice A has a $100 fee and $50 of interest, which is $150. Choice B has no fee and $200 of interest. A costs $50 less than B.

  4. Tool or trap?

    Moving debt does not remove it. The plan works only if you stop adding new debt, and a card that shows $0 owed can tempt you to use it again. New buys on the transfer card may also be charged interest right away, even while the moved balance is at 0%.

    Nia moves $5,000 to a new card, then charges $500 on the old one. Nia now owes $5,000 plus $500, which is $5,500, and has two cards to pay.

Key words

balance transfer
moving what you owe on one card to another card
promotional APR
a low yearly rate that lasts only for a limited time
transfer fee
a charge for moving a balance, usually a percent of the amount
consolidation loan
a new loan used to pay off several debts so you make one payment

Common questions

How does this fit avalanche and snowball?
Avalanche means extra money goes to the highest rate first. Snowball means extra goes to the smallest balance first. Moving a balance to a lower rate can help either plan, once the fee and the end date are checked.
Can a late payment end the low rate?
It can. The CFPB, the government agency that protects people who borrow, says that if you are more than 60 days late, the card company can raise the rate on all you owe. The card’s terms list what else can end the low rate.

Remember this

Consolidation moves debt. Paying it down, with no new debt, removes it.

Try it: Run the numbers on moving a debt

  1. List each debt you owe with its balance and its rate.
  2. Work out what a transfer fee would be: the balance times the fee percent.
  3. Write down the date a low rate would end.
  4. Run the payoff comparison, then run it again with a lower rate.

Use the public Debt Avalanche vs. Snowball calculator, or work the numbers on paper.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

  • Consolidating card debt: promotional rates last a limited time; transfer fee is usually a percent or a fixed amount, whichever is more; new purchases get no grace period; more than 60 days late can raise the rate; longer loans can cost more overall

    Source: CFPB(opens in a new tab)
  • A card company is permitted to charge a balance transfer fee on a zero percent offer

    Source: CFPB(opens in a new tab)
  • Telemarketing Sales Rule guide (July 2010): for-profit debt relief sellers by phone can’t collect fees until at least one debt is settled and a payment made

    Source: FTC(opens in a new tab)

Practice with real numbers:Try the debt payoff comparison

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.