Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Employee or Contractor?

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: Being an employee or a contractor changes your taxes, your protections and your benefits. How the work really goes decides which one you are, not the name on a paper.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: Being an employee or a contractor changes your taxes, your protections and your benefits. How the work really goes decides which one you are, not the name on a paper.

The story: Sully’s flower job

Sully gets a flower delivery job where the shop calls Sully a contractor. Wrenna, who paints signs for shops, explains how employees and contractors differ.

  1. Narrator: Sully got a job delivering flowers for a shop. The owner says, “You’re a contractor.” Sully asks a friend, Wrenna, what that means.
  2. Narrator: An employee works for an employer, the business that pays them. The employer decides what work gets done and how to do it.
  3. Wrenna: I paint signs for shops. I pick my jobs, use my own paint and set my price. I’m an independent contractor: I work for myself and get paid by the job.
  4. Narrator: Sully’s shop sets Sully’s hours, lends Sully a van and says exactly how to do each delivery. But the owner still says contractor.
  5. Sully: So which one am I? The name on my paper says contractor, but it feels like a regular job.
  6. Wrenna: A name doesn’t decide it. The IRS, the tax office, looks at who controls the work, who controls the money side, and how you and the shop are tied together.
  7. Narrator: Calling a real employee a contractor is misclassification. It can cost the worker protections the law gives employees.
  8. Narrator: One is the minimum wage, the lowest hourly pay allowed. Another is overtime, extra pay for hours past 40 in a week.
  9. Narrator: Tax is money people pay the government. An employer holds back tax from each employee’s paycheck. A contractor is usually paid with nothing held back.
  10. Narrator: Sully lists who sets the hours, who supplies the van and who decides how to deliver. Sully will show it to a parent and ask the state labor department.

What you’ll learn

  1. Two kinds of worker

    An employee works for an employer, the business that pays them. The employer controls what work gets done and how. An independent contractor is a person who works for themselves and is paid by the job. They pick their jobs and how to do them.

    A bakery tells a helper which mornings to come in and how to box each cake. That helper looks like an employee.

  2. How the government decides

    The IRS, the government’s tax office, looks at three things: who controls the work, who controls the money side, like pay and tools, and how the two are tied together, like contracts or vacation pay. No one thing decides it. For taxes, a signed paper that says contractor is only one fact.

    Hours set by a shop, a shop’s van and a shop’s shirt point toward employee. Your own tools, your own prices and many clients point toward contractor.

  3. Taxes and paperwork

    Tax is money people pay the government. An employer holds back tax from each paycheck and pays its own share of Social Security, which pays people who retire, and Medicare, health care for people 65 and up. A contractor’s pay usually has nothing held back, so the contractor sets tax money aside.

    Early each year, an employee gets a W-2 form showing the pay and the tax held back. A contractor may get a 1099 form showing what a client paid. The pay counts even if no form comes.

  4. Protections and benefits

    Most employees are covered by the minimum wage, the lowest hourly pay allowed, and by overtime, extra pay past 40 hours a week. Workers’ compensation, or workers’ comp, is help for workers hurt on the job, and each state runs its own. Misclassification can cost a worker these.

    A worker is hurt on the job at a private company. The worker contacts the state workers’ compensation board, which decides whether that worker counts as an employee.

Key words

independent contractor
a person who works for themselves and is paid by the job
employee
a worker whose employer decides what work gets done and how
misclassification
treating a real employee as a contractor
workers’ comp
help for workers hurt on the job, run by each state
Also called: workers’ compensation

Common questions

What if I think I was misclassified?
The Department of Labor says that for minimum wage and overtime law, any label on the job, even in a signed agreement, does not decide it. Ask your state labor department or the Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division.
Can a contractor get unemployment insurance?
Unemployment insurance is pay from a state for some workers who lose work. The Department of Labor says being called a contractor does not stop you from asking for it. Each state’s agency decides if you were really an employee.
Who decides if I count as an employee for workers’ comp?
The Department of Labor says each state’s workers’ compensation board decides that for workers at private companies. A worker hurt on the job there should contact that board.
What is the self-employment tax rate?
It is Social Security and Medicare tax for people who work for themselves: 15.3% of most of their net earnings, what the work brings in minus its costs. It applies once net earnings reach $400 in a year.

Remember this

How the work really goes decides it, not the word on the paper.

Try it: Employee or contractor?

  1. Find one job post, like a delivery or tutoring ad.
  2. Underline words about hours, tools, pay and who decides how to do the work.
  3. Decide whether the job looks like employee or contractor work, and write why in one sentence.

The whole mission; no account or app needed.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.