What Does "Free" Cost?
A Money Detectives lesson. This page is for grown-ups: preview it before your kid plays, or talk about it after.
Many free apps and games are paid for with your time, attention and information, so ask how the app makes money.
For ages 8–10 (grades 3–5) · about 15 minutes · read-aloud on every screen
Play this lessonWhat your kid learns
Free apps still cost money to make
People build apps, and building them costs money. So an app that costs $0 to get still has to earn money some other way. Free-to-play means a game or app costs nothing to start, and it earns money in other ways. So ask: how does it pay?
Ads, extras and data
Free apps often earn money three ways: ads, extras to buy, and data. Data is information about you and what you do, like which games you play. Tracking means watching what you do to learn about you. The FTC, a government agency that helps shoppers, says tracking lets advertisers show you ads based on your interests.
Your attention is worth something
Attention is your time and your thinking. Look for things that keep you looking and playing: scrolling that never ends, a reward for coming back every day, and pop-ups that ask you to buy. Spot the clue, then decide when to stop.
Take control
With a grown-up, you can set a time limit, say no when an app asks for things like your contacts, and ask before any buy. A grown-up can also look in the phone’s privacy settings to see what an app can reach. Some apps have no ads, so a grown-up can look for those.
The story: The Case of the Free Zoo
On a phone screen, Priya and Marcus find four clues showing how a free game called Bubble Zoo makes money, then make a rules card with a grown-up.
- Helper: New case, detectives! Priya found a game called Bubble Zoo. It costs $0 to get, so it is free. But apps cost money to make.
- Priya: If the game is free, how does Bubble Zoo make money? Let’s hunt for clues.
- Marcus: Clue one: a button says, “Watch an ad to get an extra life.” A company pays Bubble Zoo to show its ad.
- Priya: Clue two: a coin shop. Some players pay real money for extras. A game that is free to start with extras to buy is called free-to-play.
- Marcus: Clue three: a note says, “We use what you tap to pick your ads.” Data is information about you and what you do.
- Priya: Watching what you do in an app to learn about you is called tracking. A grown-up can check what an app is allowed to see.
- Marcus: Clue four: a star for opening the game every day. The game wants your attention. Attention is your time and your thinking.
- Helper: Your attention is worth something. A prize for coming back every day is there to bring you back, so notice when it feels hard to stop.
- Priya: I can take control. With a grown-up, I make a rules card: a time limit, a check of what the app can see, and ask before any buy.
- Helper: Case closed! If it is free, ask: how does it pay?
The game: How Does It Pay?
Tap every clue that shows how the app makes money. Some lines are not clues.
Games use pretend money and work with taps or a keyboard. Nothing is timed.
New words
- attention
- your time and your thinking
- data
- information about you and what you do
- tracking
- watching what you do to learn about you
- free-to-play
- free to start, and earns money in other ways
Questions at the end
- A free game gives a star for opening it every day. What is the game after?
- A free music app keeps a list of the songs you pick most. What is that list?
- Which is one way to take control of a free app?
Remember this
If it is free, ask: how does it pay?
Talk about it
Ask: which app is hardest to put down, and why do you think that is?
Try it at home: Find one setting
- With a grown-up, open one app’s settings.
- Find one setting about privacy or time.
- No device handy? Look at the app screens in the lesson and say how each one earns money.
This whole mission is free. No account or app needed.
For grown-ups: live facts
Third-party tracking lets advertisers show you targeted ads based on your interests and online activity.
Source: FTC: How To Protect Your Privacy on Apps(opens in a new tab)Some apps may ask for access to information from your device, like your location, your contacts, or your photos.
Source: FTC: How To Protect Your Privacy on Apps(opens in a new tab)Go to the privacy settings on your smartphone to see what information they can access from your device.
Source: FTC: How To Protect Your Privacy on Apps(opens in a new tab)
School standards
- National Standards for Personal Financial Education: Spending
- National Standards for Personal Financial Education: Managing Risk
Builds on
Leads to
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.