Cheap or Smart?
A Money Detectives lesson. This page is for grown-ups: preview it before your kid plays, or talk about it after.
The cheapest choice is not always the best deal, so think about how long it lasts and how often you will use it.
For ages 8–10 (grades 3–5) · about 15 minutes · read-aloud on every screen
Play this lessonWhat your kid learns
Cheap is not always smart
Quality means how well a thing is made and how long it lasts. A cheap price tag can hide poor quality. Smart means the best choice for what you need, and the lowest price is not always it.
Cost per use
Cost per use is the price divided by how many times you use a thing. Divide means split into equal parts. A cheap thing used a few times can cost more for each use than a pricey thing used many times.
Sometimes cheap is fine
If you will use a thing only once, it does not need to last. Paying more for quality you will not use is not smart. The best choice depends on how many times you will use it.
Check the quality
Ask people who own it how long it lasted. A review is what someone who bought a thing says about it. Look at reviews with a grown-up. A brand is the name a company puts on its things. A brand name alone does not tell you how long a thing lasts.
The story: The Case of the Two Umbrellas
In a store, Mei compares a cheap $4 umbrella that lasts 2 rainy days with a sturdy $10 umbrella that lasts 20 rainy days. The sturdy one costs less each day.
- Helper: New case, detectives! Mei needs an umbrella for rainy days. The store has two. Which one is the smart buy?
- Mei: The cheap umbrella costs $4. The sturdy umbrella costs $10. I will take the cheap one!
- Seller: Wait. Quality is how well a thing is made and how long it lasts. Owners say the cheap one flips inside out after 2 rainy days.
- Helper: Owners say the sturdy one lasts 20 rainy days. Cost per use is the price split across every time you use a thing.
- Helper: The cheap umbrella costs $4 for 2 rainy days. Split $4 into 2 equal parts, and each day costs $2.
- Helper: The sturdy umbrella costs $10 for 20 rainy days. Split $10 into 20 equal parts. Each day costs 50¢, which is half a dollar.
- Mei: The cheap umbrella costs more every time I use it! The sturdy one costs less each day.
- Helper: Smart means the best choice for what you need. For an umbrella you use on many rainy days, sturdy is smart. For a thing you use once, cheap can be smart.
- Seller: To check quality, ask people who own the umbrella. Or look at what owners wrote, with a grown-up. What an owner writes is called a review.
- Helper: Case closed! Cheap now can cost more later. Think about how often you will use it.
The game: Fast-Forward
Pick one option. Then skip ahead and see what happened, with the cost for each use.
Games use pretend money and work with taps or a keyboard. Nothing is timed.
New words
- quality
- how well a thing is made and how long it lasts
- cost per use
- the price divided by how many times you use a thing
- review
- what someone who bought a thing says about it
- brand
- the name a company puts on its things
Questions at the end
- What is a review?
- A ball costs $12. You play with it in 3 games, and then it pops. What is the cost per use?
- A backpack has a famous brand name on it. Does the name alone tell you how long it will last?
Remember this
Cheap now can cost more later.
Talk about it
Pick something we have owned for years. How many times have we used it? Was it a smart buy?
Try it at home: Find your cost per use
- With a grown-up, find something you have owned for a long time.
- Guess how many times you have used it. A guess is fine.
- Pick a price. A made-up price is fine. Split the price by the uses.
No old things handy? Pick any toy or shoes you own, make up a price, guess the uses, and split.
School standards
- National Standards for Personal Financial Education: Spending
- Common Core Math 3.OA.A.3
- Common Core Math 3.OA.C.7
Builds on
Leads to
Go deeper
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.