Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Sequence Risk: Bad Timing Hurts Most at the Start

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: Once you take money out every year, the order of good and bad years matters, not just the average. Losses in the first years hurt most.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: Once you take money out every year, the order of good and bad years matters, not just the average. Losses in the first years hurt most.

The story: Same years, opposite order

Walt and Grace work through two years of gains and losses in both orders, and see that losses first leaves them with less once they take money out.

  1. Narrator: Walt and Grace just retired with $600,000 saved and invested. Invested means put into things whose prices go up and down. They test taking out $36,000 a year.
  2. Walt: A return is what our investments gain or lose in a year. If they average about 7% a year, the order of good and bad years shouldn’t matter. Right?
  3. Narrator: With nothing taken out, Walt is right. $100,000 that loses 20% drops by $20,000, to $80,000. A 20% gain then adds $16,000, making $96,000.
  4. Narrator: Flip the order. A 20% gain makes $120,000. A 20% loss then takes $24,000, and it’s $96,000 again. Same end.
  5. Narrator: Now take out $10,000 at the end of each year. Loss first: $80,000, minus $10,000, is $70,000.
  6. Narrator: Then a 20% gain: 20% of $70,000 is $14,000, so $84,000. Minus $10,000 leaves $74,000.
  7. Narrator: Gain first: $120,000, minus $10,000, is $110,000. A 20% loss takes $22,000, so $88,000. Minus $10,000 leaves $78,000.
  8. Grace: Same two years, and the loss first leaves us $4,000 behind. Money we take out in a bad year isn’t there to grow when prices come back.
  9. Narrator: Over 25 years of taking $36,000, a run of losses first makes their money run out in year 20. With good years first, it lasts all 25.
  10. Narrator: Same average, opposite order, very different results. That’s sequence risk.

What you’ll learn

  1. What sequence risk is

    A return is what your investments gain or lose in a year, as a percent. If you never put money in or take money out, the order of good and bad years doesn’t change where you end up. Once you take money out every year, it does. Sequence risk is the harm from bad years coming first, while you’re taking money out.

    No money out: $100,000, minus 20%, is $80,000, and plus 20% is $96,000. Flip it: plus 20% is $120,000, and minus 20% is $96,000.

  2. Why early losses hurt most

    In a bad year, you still have bills, so you sell investments while prices are low. The money you took out is gone before prices come back. Smaller savings then grow less in the good years that follow.

    Take out $10,000 a year. Loss then gain: $100,000 becomes $70,000, then $74,000. Gain then loss: $110,000, then $78,000.

  3. The danger zone

    The years just before and just after you retire matter most. Your savings are at their biggest, and you’re just starting to take money out. A big drop then does more harm than the same drop 15 years later. And savings that shrink need a bigger percent gain to get back.

    $100,000 that falls by half is $50,000. To get back to $100,000, it has to double. That’s a 100% gain, not a 50% one.

  4. Defenses you control

    No one can choose the order of market years, but you can choose your plan. Keep a cash reserve to spend in bad years. Plan spending that can shrink for a while. If you haven’t started Social Security, waiting raises the check for life. Part-time work helps too. Each one means selling less while prices are low.

Key words

return
what your investments gain or lose in a year, as a percent
withdrawal
money you take out of savings
sequence risk
harm from bad market years coming first, while you take money out
Also called: sequence-of-returns risk
danger zone
the years just before and after retiring
Also called: retirement red zone

Common questions

Are the returns in the game real history?
No. They were picked to show the idea clearly. Real markets have had runs of bad years early in some people’s retirements, though.
Should I move everything to cash before I retire?
That trades one risk for another. Cash doesn’t drop with the market, but it can fall behind rising prices. Many people keep a cash reserve and leave the rest invested. A planner can help you weigh your own mix.

Remember this

It’s not just the returns. It’s the order.

Try it: Test your plan against bad years

  1. Run your numbers in the public retirement calculator.
  2. Run them again with a lower yearly return, and see how the result changes.
  3. Write down one defense that could fit you: cash, spending that can shrink, waiting on Social Security or part-time work.

No account: use the public Retirement Calculator (/tools/retirement-calculator).

Practice with real numbers:Try the retirement calculator

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.