Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

That Old Life Insurance Policy: Keep, Change or Cash Out?

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: An old policy can be worth money or quietly cost it. Find out what it is worth and what it costs before you decide.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: An old policy can be worth money or quietly cost it. Find out what it is worth and what it costs before you decide.

The story: A policy in the drawer

Agatha finds an old universal life policy, asks the insurer for an in-force illustration, sees the cash value may run out, and with Agatha’s son Ozzie weighs keeping, borrowing, cashing in, swapping or selling.

  1. Narrator: Agatha finds an old life insurance policy. It pays a death benefit, money for the person named, when Agatha dies. That person is Agatha’s son, Ozzie.
  2. Narrator: It is universal life, coverage that can last a lifetime, with a cash account inside. The cash value is what the policy is worth if Agatha cashes it in.
  3. Narrator: A letter says the cost is going up. Agatha’s premium, the policy’s price, is $50 a month, and Agatha has paid it for 20 years.
  4. Narrator: $50 times 12 is $600 a year. $600 times 20 is $12,000 paid in so far.
  5. Agatha: I will ask the insurance company for an in-force illustration, a projection of this policy from today. It shows how long the cash value may last.
  6. Narrator: It says the cash value is $15,000 today, but costs keep rising. If the cash runs out, the policy can end. That is called a lapse.
  7. Narrator: Ozzie asks about the choices. Agatha can keep it, borrow against it, cash it in, swap it for another policy, or sell it.
  8. Narrator: To surrender is to cash it in and end it. $15,000 minus the $12,000 paid in is $3,000. That $3,000 is usually taxed as income.
  9. Agatha: Before I choose, I ask three things. What is it worth? What does it cost? And what happens if I stop paying?

What you’ll learn

  1. What an old policy is

    A life insurance policy pays a death benefit, money for the person you name, when the insured, the person whose life is covered, dies. The premium is its price. Term covers a set number of years and pays only for a death in that time. Permanent can last for life and builds cash value, what it is worth if cashed in.

    Archibald’s term policy covers 20 years. If Archibald dies in year 21, it pays nothing. A whole life policy, a kind of permanent, would still pay.

  2. A policy can end

    Universal life is permanent coverage with a cash account inside. The policy stays active only while the cash value can cover its costs. If costs rise and the cash runs out, the policy can end, called a lapse. An in-force illustration, a projection of your policy from today, shows how long it may last.

    Sterling’s policy has $10,000 of cash value, and $2,000 of costs come out each year. $10,000 divided by $2,000 is 5. With nothing new paid in, it lasts 5 years.

  3. Keep, borrow, cash in or swap

    You can keep paying. You can borrow against the cash value, which adds interest and lowers what your beneficiary gets. You can surrender it, which means cash it in and end it, and money over the premiums you paid is usually taxed. Or you can swap it for another life policy, tax-free if it qualifies.

    Penelope has paid $20,000 in premiums, and cashing in gives $25,000. $25,000 minus $20,000 is $5,000, and that $5,000 is usually taxed as income.

  4. Selling it, or an early payout

    A life settlement is selling a policy to a company for less than its death benefit. The buyer pays the premiums and collects the benefit. It generally pays more than cashing in, but costs can be high and it can be taxed, so get several offers. Also ask about an accelerated death benefit, part of the benefit paid early.

    Delphina has a terminal illness, one expected to end in death, and the policy has an early payout for that. Delphina asks the insurer before calling any buyer.

Key words

cash value
what the policy is worth if you cash it in
in-force illustration
a projection of your policy from today
life settlement
selling a policy to a company for less than its death benefit
accelerated death benefit
part of the death benefit paid early

Common questions

How do I find a policy a loved one who died may have had?
A free locator run by state insurance officials sends your request to insurance companies. Anyone can use it. You enter details from the death certificate. If a company finds a policy and you are the beneficiary, it contacts you. If not, you hear nothing.
Can I ask the insurer for an in-force illustration?
Yes, you can ask. A model rule from state insurance officials, which states can adopt, says owners may ask for one each year at no charge, and to call the state insurance department if none arrives within 30 days. Ask your insurer about its process.
What else should I know before selling a policy?
State insurance officials say to ask a tax adviser, because the money is tax-free only in some cases. Creditors, people you owe, could claim it, and public help such as Medicaid could be affected. Your state insurance department can explain the laws that protect you.
Should I replace an old policy with a new one?
FINRA, a group that oversees investment firms, says a new policy will likely bring new charges for cashing it in early, and a new period when the insurer can question a claim. Not every swap is tax-free. Ask for illustrations of both policies and compare the costs.

Remember this

Ask what it is worth, what it costs, and what happens if you stop paying.

Try it: List your policies and what to ask

  1. List each life insurance policy: the company, term or permanent, the death benefit and the premium.
  2. Ask each company for the policy’s cash value, and for an in-force illustration if it is universal life.
  3. Add each cash value in Assets and each premium in Bills, with keep, change or drop in the bill’s note.
  4. Next to each, write three questions: what is it worth, what does it cost, and what happens if payments stop.

No account: use the public Net Worth Calculator at /tools/net-worth-calculator, or a sheet of paper.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

  • “Term life insurance offers coverage for a set period of time.”; “Whole life insurance offers a fixed amount of coverage that lasts for the insured’s entire life.”; “The policy remains active as long as the cash value is enough to cover insurance costs.”; “Loans may be taken against the cash value.”

    Source: NAIC: Life insurance(opens in a new tab)
  • “The cash value is the accumulation of premiums collected minus expenses and charges.”; “you will be charged interest”; “the amount you borrow from the life policy reduces the amount your beneficiaries will receive if you die.”

    Source: NAIC: Life Insurance Roadmap(opens in a new tab)
  • “Upon the request of the policy owner, the insurer shall furnish an in force illustration of current and future benefits and values based on the insurer’s present illustrated scale.”; the owner notice: “You may annually request, without charge, such an illustration”; “If you do not receive a current illustration of your policy within 30 days from your request, you should contact your state insurance department.”

    Source: NAIC Life Insurance Illustrations Model Regulation (#582), a model that states may adopt(opens in a new tab)
  • If you surrender a policy for cash, you “must include in income any proceeds that are more than the cost of the life insurance policy”; “In most cases, your cost (or investment in the contract) is the total of premiums that you paid for the life insurance policy, less any refunded premiums, rebates, dividends, or unrepaid loans that weren’t included in your income.”; accelerated death benefits “are excluded from income if the insured is terminally or chronically ill”

    Source: IRS Publication 525: Taxable and Nontaxable Income(opens in a new tab)
  • “No gain or loss shall be recognized on the exchange of— a contract of life insurance for another contract of life insurance or for an endowment or annuity contract”

    Source: Cornell LII: 26 U.S.C. § 1035(opens in a new tab)
  • “not all replacements are Section 1035 Exchanges and, as a consequence, not all are tax-free”; “The new policy will likely have its own new surrender charge schedule”; “The new policy typically will have a new contestability period.”

    Source: FINRA: Should You Exchange Your Life Insurance Policy?(opens in a new tab)
  • A life settlement “involves selling an existing life insurance policy to a third party”; “Life settlements can have high transaction costs”; payments are “generally more than the policy’s cash surrender value”; the lump sum “can be taxable, depending on your circumstances”; “While the majority of states regulate life settlements”; “You might also be eligible for accelerated death benefits”

    Source: FINRA: What You Should Know About Life Settlements(opens in a new tab)
  • A life settlement is “the sale of a life insurance policy to another person or company in return for a cash payment of less than the full amount of the death benefit”; “Know that your creditors could claim the proceeds.”; “Proceeds are only tax-free under certain circumstances.”; “Contact your state insurance department for information about current laws that may protect you.”

    Source: NAIC: Understanding Life Settlements(opens in a new tab)
  • The locator is a “free online tool” that “is available to anyone”; if a policy is found and you are the beneficiary, “the life insurance or annuity company will contact you directly”

    Source: NAIC: Life Insurance Policy Locator(opens in a new tab)

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.