Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free
Medigap or Medicare Advantage?
- Warm-up
- Story
- Learn
- Play
- Quiz
- Remember
- Try it
- Finish
About this lesson
About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions
The big idea: Original Medicare leaves part of each bill for you. Medigap pays most of it for a higher monthly price. Medicare Advantage costs less each month but more when you get care.
Lesson outline
The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more
The big idea: Original Medicare leaves part of each bill for you. Medigap pays most of it for a higher monthly price. Medicare Advantage costs less each month but more when you get care.
The story: Grace weighs the trade-off
Grace compares a Medicare Advantage ad with Walt’s Medigap plan, and learns why the first six months with Part B matter.
- Narrator: Grace turns 65 next month, so Medicare starts. Medicare is the government’s health insurance for people 65 and older.
- Narrator: Original Medicare is Parts A and B: A for hospital stays, B for doctors and tests. It pays most of each bill, but not all of it.
- Grace: For most doctor bills, Medicare pays 80% and I pay 20%. On a $10,000 bill, 20% is one fifth. $10,000 divided by 5 is $2,000.
- Narrator: And Original Medicare has no yearly limit on that share. So most people add more coverage, in one of two ways.
- Narrator: One way is Medigap: extra insurance from a private company, not the government. It works with Original Medicare and pays most of the share Medicare leaves.
- Walt: I have Medigap. With my drug plan, it costs about $200 a month. But a big bill costs me very little, and any doctor who takes Medicare works.
- Narrator: The other way is Medicare Advantage, a private plan you pick instead of Original Medicare. A premium is the monthly price, and its premium is often low.
- Grace: This one is $20 a month. But I pay a set amount each visit, and it covers only the doctors on its list. We spend every winter in Arizona.
- Narrator: One more thing. For six months after Grace’s Part B starts, any Medigap company must sell Grace a plan. Later, most can say no.
- Grace: So I’ll compare both ways now, while every Medigap company still has to say yes.
What you’ll learn
What Original Medicare leaves for you
Original Medicare is Parts A and B: A for hospital stays, B for doctors and tests. It pays most of each bill, not all. For most doctor care, it pays 80% and you pay the other 20%. There is no yearly limit on your share. So most people add more coverage, in one of two ways.
A $10,000 doctor bill. 20% is one fifth, and $10,000 divided by 5 is $2,000. Medicare pays the rest, and you owe $2,000.
Way one: Medigap
Medigap is extra insurance from a private company. It works with Original Medicare and pays most of your share of each bill. You pay it a premium. A premium is the monthly price. Any doctor who takes Medicare works, anywhere in the country. For drugs, you add a separate Part D drug plan.
Medigap and a drug plan at $200 a month: $200 times 12 months is $2,400 a year. A big bill adds little, so a sick year costs about the same.
Way two: Medicare Advantage
Medicare Advantage, also called Part C, is a private plan you pick instead of Original Medicare. It usually covers drugs, and its premium is often low. You pay a copay each time you get care, up to a yearly limit. A copay is a set amount. Most plans cover only doctors in their network. The network is the plan’s list.
Advantage at $20 a month: $20 times 12 is $240 a year. With a $5,000 yearly limit, a very sick year can cost $240 plus $5,000, which is $5,240.
Your first six months matter
For six months, starting when you have Part B and are 65 or older, any Medigap company must sell you a plan, and can’t charge more because of your health. Later, in most states, it can say no or charge more. Agents who sell plans are paid by the plans. SHIP is a free program in every state. Its counselors sell nothing.
Key words
- Medigap
- extra insurance that pays most of what Original Medicare leaves
- Also called: Medicare Supplement Insurance
- Medicare Advantage
- a private plan you pick instead of Original Medicare
- Also called: Medicare Part C
- network
- the list of doctors and hospitals a plan works with
- copay
- a set amount you pay each time you get care
Common questions
- What if I try Advantage first and don’t like it?
- If you join an Advantage plan when you first get Medicare and leave within the first year, a one-time trial right usually lets you go back to Original Medicare and buy a Medigap plan. Check the rules on Medicare.gov.
- I already picked a plan. Can I change it?
- Each fall there’s a yearly window to change plans. Moving from Advantage back to Medigap may depend on your state and your health, so a free SHIP counselor is a good first call.
- Someone called offering a “free” Medicare plan review. Is that okay?
- Be careful. Medicare won’t call you to sell a plan. Hang up and call your state’s SHIP program instead, which is free and sells nothing.
Remember this
Medigap costs more each month and less when you’re sick. Advantage is the reverse.
Try it: Compare plans in your ZIP code
- Open the Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov and enter your ZIP code.
- List your doctors and drugs, and check them in each plan.
- Or book a free appointment with your state’s SHIP counselor.
The whole mission works with no account or app.
Live facts
Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.
Medicare starts at
65
The age most people become eligible for Medicare
As of November 20, 2026
Source: Medicare.gov(opens in a new tab)Medigap open window, trial rights and state rules
Source: Medicare.gov(opens in a new tab)Compare plans in your ZIP code (Plan Finder)
Source: Medicare.gov(opens in a new tab)Free, unbiased Medicare counseling (SHIP)
Source: SHIPhelp.org(opens in a new tab)
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.