Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free
Trim Line, Raise Line: Spending That Flexes
- Warm-up
- Story
- Learn
- Play
- Quiz
- Remember
- Try it
- Finish
About this lesson
About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions
The big idea: Decide ahead of time to spend a little less if your savings fall, and a little more if they grow. With that plan written down, many people can start a little higher.
Lesson outline
The big idea: Decide ahead of time to spend a little less if your savings fall, and a little more if they grow. With that plan written down, many people can start a little higher.
The story: Walt and Grace write two lines
Walt and Grace write down a trim line and a raise line, so a market drop or a strong year leads to a small, planned change in spending.
- Narrator: Walt and Grace have $600,000 saved. They want to take out $30,000 a year. 1% of $600,000 is $6,000, and $30,000 is 5 times that, so that’s 5%.
- Walt: The 4% rule would say $24,000. What if the market drops right after we start? Then $30,000 a year could be too much.
- Grace: Then let’s decide now what we’d do. We write two lines: a trim line below what we have today, and a raise line above it.
- Narrator: If their savings fall below $500,000, they take out 10% less. 10% of $30,000 is $3,000, so they take $27,000.
- Grace: And the $3,000 comes only from wants, like trips and gifts. Our needs, like food and medicine, stay paid.
- Narrator: If their savings climb above $750,000, they take out 10% more. $30,000 plus $3,000 is $33,000. In between, they keep taking $30,000.
- Walt: With a plan for bad years already written down, we can start at $30,000 and worry less.
What you’ll learn
What trim and raise lines are
A trim line is a savings amount below what you have today. If your savings fall under it, you spend a little less. A raise line is an amount above what you have today. If your savings climb over it, you give yourself a raise. You write down both lines, and how much you’d change, while markets are calm.
Walt and Grace have $600,000. Their trim line is $500,000, and their raise line is $750,000.
Where the lines come from
Your withdrawal rate is what you take out in a year, as a percent of your savings. When savings fall, the same dollars become a bigger percent, which uses up savings faster. When savings grow, the same dollars become a smaller percent, so there’s room for more.
$30,000 from $600,000 is 5%. At $500,000, 1% is $5,000, so $30,000 is 6%. At $750,000, 4% of $700,000 is $28,000, and 4% of $50,000 is $2,000. Together that’s $30,000, so 4%.
Trim the wants, never the needs
Needs are the basic version of what you must pay for: housing, food, medicine and insurance. Anything above the basic version is a want: trips, gifts, eating out and big projects. Only wants get trimmed. Sorting your spending into needs and wants is part of writing the plan.
A $60 phone plan covers the need. A $100 plan is $60 of need and $40 of want.
Why a plan lets you start higher
A rule that never changes spending has to start low to get through the worst years. When you’ve agreed to trim in bad years, your savings get extra protection when they need it, so many people can start a little higher. Check your savings once a year, and act only when a line is crossed.
Key words
- trim line
- a savings amount that, if crossed going down, starts a small spending cut
- Also called: guardrail
- raise line
- a savings amount that, if crossed going up, starts a spending raise
- Also called: guardrail
- withdrawal rate
- what you take out in a year, as a percent of your savings
- want
- anything above the basic version of a need, like trips and gifts
Common questions
- How far apart should the lines be?
- People set them differently. Lines too close together mean frequent changes, and lines too far apart act too late. A planner can help you test choices.
- Do I trim forever once I cross the line?
- No. Many people check once a year. If savings climb back above the trim line, the trim can end.
Remember this
Below the trim line, trim a little. Above the raise line, enjoy a raise.
Try it: Write your trim and raise lines
- Write down your savings total today.
- Pick a trim line below it and a raise line above it, in dollars.
- Write how much you’d trim or raise your wants at each line, and keep it with your money papers.
An index card or a sheet of paper (no account needed).
Builds on
Leads to
Practice with real numbers:Try the retirement calculator
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.