Phone Showdown: The Total Cost
A Level Up lesson. This page is for grown-ups: preview it before your kid plays, or talk about it after.
A phone costs the phone plus the plan, fees and protection, added up over the whole time you keep it. Compare totals, not monthly prices.
For ages 11–13 (grades 6–8) · about 15 minutes · read-aloud on every screen
Play this lessonWhat your kid learns
A $0 down phone is borrowing
A device payment plan splits a phone’s price into equal monthly payments. $0 down means you pay nothing on the first day, but you still owe the whole price. Money you borrow and pay back over time is a loan. Many phone loans charge no interest, which is an extra cost for borrowing. Every payment is still owed.
Prepaid, monthly and family plans
Prepaid means you pay for service before you use it. A monthly plan sends you a bill each month. A family plan is one plan shared by a family, and each phone pays a share. To find a share, split the plan’s price by the number of phones.
Buy only the data you will use
Data is the internet your phone uses when it is not connected at home or school. Plans with more data cost more. Look at how much data you really use, and pick a plan that fits. Extra data you never use costs money for nothing.
Add up everything for the whole time
Total cost of ownership is everything you pay over the whole time you keep something. For a phone, that is the phone, the plan, protection, and taxes and fees, which are extra charges. Protection is a monthly payment so a broken phone is fixed or replaced.
The story: Calix and the $0 down phone
In a phone shop, Calix and a worker compare a $0 down phone with a $50 plan, $1,800 over two years, with buying the same $600 phone and using a $15 prepaid plan for $960.
- Helper: Calix’s family is shopping for Calix’s first phone, and a grown-up will sign for it. Calix wants to know what it really costs.
- Seller: This phone is $600, and it is $0 down! You pay $25 a month for 24 months.
- Helper: A device payment plan splits a phone’s price into monthly payments. $0 down means you pay nothing today. But all $600 is still owed, so it is borrowing.
- Helper: 24 payments of $25 make the $600 price, so this plan adds no extra cost. If the family stops the plan early, the rest is still owed.
- Helper: Service, the plan that lets a phone call, text and use the internet, costs $50 a month. With the phone’s $25, that is $75 a month.
- Helper: Total cost of ownership is everything you pay while you keep something. Calix keeps it 2 years. 12 months of $75 is $900. Twice that is $1,800.
- Calix: That is three times the phone’s price! Is there a cheaper way?
- Helper: Yes. A grown-up buys the same $600 phone. Then a prepaid plan, service you pay for before you use it, costs $15 a month.
- Helper: Two years is 24 months. 24 months of $15 is $360. With the $600 phone, the two years cost $960 in all.
- Helper: The phone is $600 both ways, so the plan makes the difference. Prepaid is $35 less each month. Over 24 months, that is $840 less.
The game: Plan showdown
Maelle needs a phone for one year, which is 12 months. Add up every cost, then pick the choice that costs less.
Games use pretend money and work with taps or a keyboard. Nothing is timed.
New words
- device payment plan
- a way to pay for a phone in equal monthly payments
- Also called: installment loan
- prepaid
- service you pay for before you use it
- data
- the internet your phone uses when it is not connected at home or school
- total cost of ownership
- everything you pay over the whole time you keep something
Questions at the end
- What does $0 down mean?
- What is a prepaid plan?
- A plan costs $12 a month. One year is $144. How much do 2 years cost?
- A family plan costs $140 a month for 4 phones. What is each phone’s share?
- Which things belong in the total cost of owning a phone?
Remember this
Add it up for the whole time you keep it.
Talk about it
Does our phone have a monthly payment for the phone itself? How many months are left?
Try it at home: Add up one phone line
- If your family is comfortable sharing, ask a grown-up what one phone line costs each month.
- Ask if the phone itself is still being paid for, and how many months are left.
- Multiply the monthly cost by 12 for one year, then double it for two years.
Use Calix’s numbers from the story: $75 a month for 2 years, or a $600 phone plus $15 a month for 2 years. Find each total.
School standards
- Grades 6–8
- National Standards for Personal Financial Education: Spending
- Common Core Math 7.RP.A.3
Builds on
Leads to
Go deeper
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.