"Free" Apps Aren't Free
A Level Up lesson. This page is for grown-ups: preview it before your kid plays, or talk about it after.
When an app costs nothing, it often earns money from ads or extras, and it may collect data about you to pick ads. You can choose what an app is allowed to use.
For ages 11–13 (grades 6–8) · about 15 minutes · read-aloud on every screen
Play this lessonWhat your kid learns
How free apps earn
A free app costs $0 to download, but it can still earn money. Some show ads. Some are freemium, which means free to start, with extras you pay for. Many also collect data, facts about you like what you watch, where you are and who you know. Data can help pick the ads you see.
Your data and targeted ads
Data is facts about you, like what you watch and where you are. A targeted ad is an ad picked for you, from data about what you do. The FTC, the government agency that protects shoppers, says advertisers may use a unique advertising identifier, a code tied to your phone, to track you.
Permissions
A permission is a yes-or-no question where an app asks to use something on your phone, like your location, contacts or photos. Ask whether the app needs it to work. The FTC says to think about turning off permissions an app does not need. You can change them later in your privacy settings.
Rules for kids
A law called COPPA covers apps and sites made for kids, and ones that know a user is under 13. In most cases, they must get a parent’s okay before collecting personal information from a child under 13. The FTC says COPPA does not apply to teenagers. So at 13, your own choices matter even more.
The story: Is DoodleDash really free?
Thessaly installs a free drawing game, says no to a request to use contacts, and sees ads picked for Thessaly.
- Helper: Thessaly finds a drawing game called DoodleDash. An app is a program you use on a phone. This one costs nothing to download.
- Helper: Many free apps earn money from ads or extras. Some also collect data, which means facts about you, like what you tap and where you are.
- Thessaly: Between levels, an ad plays. Then the game asks to use my contacts, my photos and my location.
- Helper: That question is a permission, a yes-or-no question where an app asks to use something on your phone, like your location.
- Thessaly: A drawing game needs my screen. It does not need my contacts or my location. I will choose No for those.
- Helper: The game still works. It is freemium, which means free to start, with extras you can pay for.
- Helper: New brushes cost $2 each. Three brushes would cost $6.
- Helper: Later, Thessaly sees ads for paint sets. A targeted ad is an ad picked for you, from data about what you do.
- Thessaly: I can turn off permissions later in my settings. I will check them with my grown-up.
- Helper: A free app can cost your data instead of money. You get to choose what you share.
The game: Allow or say no?
An app asks for a permission. Choose Allow or No, then see what happens.
Games use pretend money and work with taps or a keyboard. Nothing is timed.
New words
- data
- facts about you, like what you watch, where you are and who you know
- targeted ad
- an ad picked for you, from data about what you do
- permission
- a yes-or-no question where an app asks to use something on your phone
- freemium
- free to start, with extras you pay for
Questions at the end
- A free app costs $0 to download. How might it still earn money?
- What is data?
- You said yes to a permission, and now you want to take it back. What can you do?
- You look at hiking boots. Later, a game shows you boot ads. What is that?
- A game is free to start, but extra levels cost $3. What is that called?
Remember this
A free app can cost your data.
Talk about it
Which apps do you use that cost nothing? What do you think they ask to use?
Try it at home: Turn off one permission
- Pick one app with a grown-up.
- Open your phone’s privacy settings and look at what the app can use.
- Turn off one permission the app does not need.
The whole mission works with no account or app.
For grown-ups: live facts
“When you use an app on your smartphone, advertisers may use a unique advertising identifier to track you.”; “Some apps may ask for access to information from your device, like your location, your contacts, or your photos.”; “Consider turning off unnecessary permissions or deleting apps that request a lot of permissions”…
Source: FTC consumer advice, How To Protect Your Privacy on Apps(opens in a new tab)“Go to the privacy settings on your smartphone to see what information they can access from your device.”
Source: FTC consumer advice, How To Protect Your Privacy on Apps(opens in a new tab)“an operator must obtain verifiable parental consent before collecting any personal information from a child, unless the collection fits into one of the Rule’s exceptions”…; “The Rule also applies to operators of general audience websites or online services with actual knowledge that they are collecting, using, or disclosing personal information from children under 13”…; “The Rule was designed to protect children under age 13”…; “Although COPPA does not apply to teenagers, the FTC is concerned about teen privacy.”
Source: FTC, Complying with COPPA: Frequently Asked Questions(opens in a new tab)
School standards
- Grades 6–8
- National Standards for Personal Financial Education: Managing Risk
Builds on
Leads to
Go deeper
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.