Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

College or Retirement: Who Gets the Next Dollar?

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: A student has ways to pay for school, such as aid and loans. Your retirement has fewer, so many parents fund their own future first and college second.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: A student has ways to pay for school, such as aid and loans. Your retirement has fewer, so many parents fund their own future first and college second.

The story: Esperanza picks where $400 goes

Esperanza sits at home and decides how to split $400 a month between retirement savings and a college fund for Haruto.

  1. Narrator: Esperanza has $400 left each month after paying bills, the money owed each month. Esperanza’s son, Haruto, is 8, and college is about 10 years away.
  2. Narrator: Esperanza asks: should the next dollar go to Haruto’s college, or to Esperanza’s retirement? Retirement means the years after you stop working for pay.
  3. Narrator: On a plane, adults put on their own oxygen mask first, because they cannot help a child if they cannot breathe. Many parents use that idea for money.
  4. Narrator: School has financial aid: money to help pay for school. It comes as grants and scholarships, which are not repaid, work-study jobs, and loans, which are repaid.
  5. Narrator: For retirement, the money mostly comes from what you save, plus Social Security, a monthly payment from the government.
  6. Narrator: Federal aid starts with the FAFSA form. It does not count retirement savings, like a 401(k) from a job, as an asset, something the family owns.
  7. Narrator: If all $400 a month goes to college, $400 times 12 is $4,800 a year. $4,800 times 10 years is $48,000 before growth, and retirement gets nothing.
  8. Narrator: Some families pick a cost share: the part of the college bill they plan to pay, not all of it. Aid, a job and the student’s savings can cover the rest.
  9. Esperanza: I will send $300 a month to my retirement and $100 to a college fund for Haruto. That keeps me safe and still gives Haruto a start.
  10. Narrator: $100 times 12 is $1,200 a year, so 10 years is $12,000 before growth. That is a start, not the whole bill. Esperanza will tell Haruto early what to expect.

What you’ll learn

  1. Put your own mask on first

    On a plane, you put on your own oxygen mask before helping a child. Many parents use that idea, a common guide, not an official rule: save for your own retirement, the years after you stop working, first, then college. A student has aid and loans for school. Your retirement money mostly comes from what you save.

    Wilfred has $200 a month left. Wilfred puts $150 toward retirement and $50 toward college. $150 plus $50 is $200, so the whole $200 has a place to go.

  2. How aid treats retirement savings

    Financial aid is money to help pay for school. A grant or scholarship is not repaid. A loan is repaid with interest, an extra charge for borrowing. For federal aid, a family fills out the FAFSA form. It does not count retirement plans, like a 401(k), a pension or an IRA, as an asset. Money taken out counts as income.

    Gwendolyn has $100,000 in a 401(k), and the form does not count it as an asset. If Gwendolyn takes out $10,000, the form counts $10,000 as income.

  3. Other ways to cover college

    Aid is not the only help. Students can earn scholarships, work part-time, and choose a school that costs less. Some families pick a cost share: the part of the college bill they plan to pay, not all of it. The student, aid and family each cover a part, so the family does not have to cover everything.

    The yearly bill is $20,000. A family aims for a cost share of half. Half of $20,000 is $10,000. Aid, work and the student cover the other $10,000.

  4. Tell your kids early

    Tell your kids early what you plan to pay and what you cannot. Kids who know can look for scholarships, plan to work, and think about cost when they pick a school. A talk at 10 is easier than a surprise at 17.

    Teodora tells a 10-year-old: the family will pay part of college, and the rest comes from aid, a job and scholarships the child wins.

Key words

oxygen-mask idea
a common guide: put your own mask on first, so save for your own future before a child’s college
financial aid
money to help pay for school: grants, scholarships, work-study jobs and loans
cost share
the part of the college bill a family aims to pay, not all of it
asset
something a family owns that has a value

Common questions

Can I take money out of retirement to pay for college?
Money taken out of most retirement accounts is taxed as income, money coming in, and before age 59½ it usually owes an extra 10% tax, with some exceptions. The aid form also counts money taken out as income. Check IRS Topic 558 first.
Does the form count a 529 plan?
The Department of Education handbook says a 529 plan for a dependent student is reported as a parent investment. The next lesson covers 529 plans.
What if I cannot save for both?
Start with a small amount toward each goal. The common order in the earlier lesson on the next dollar puts the employer match early and goals like college later.
Where can I learn about the kinds of aid?
Federal Student Aid, studentaid.gov, explains grants, work-study, scholarships and loans.

Remember this

Put your own oxygen mask on first.

Try it: Fund retirement, then set the college goal

  1. Run your retirement plan first, and write the monthly amount it needs.
  2. Take that amount away from what you have left each month.
  3. Set a college goal using the money that is left.

Guest: run it on the /demo sample household, or use the public Retirement Calculator (/tools/retirement-calculator); or write the numbers on a printed goal card.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.