Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

The Car Decision: Fix, Replace or Keep Driving

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: The car you have is usually the cheapest, until its yearly repairs cost more than replacing it really would. Compare whole years, not monthly payments.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: The car you have is usually the cheapest, until its yearly repairs cost more than replacing it really would. Compare whole years, not monthly payments.

The story: Marcus counts a year

Marcus stands by an old car with a repair bill, counts a full year of costs for fixing it and for a newer car, and then starts a car fund.

  1. Narrator: Marcus drives an old car that is fully paid for. A mechanic says it needs a $1,500 repair. Should Marcus fix it or buy a newer one?
  2. Narrator: Count one year of costs. Insurance, money you pay a company so it pays for damage after a crash, is $1,200 a year. Fuel, which means gas, is $1,200.
  3. Narrator: Other repairs are about $600. So keeping the old car is $1,500 plus $600 plus $1,200 plus $1,200. That is $4,500 a year.
  4. Seller: This newer car is $300 a month on a loan. A loan is borrowed money you pay back to the lender, the bank or company that lent it.
  5. Narrator: A year is 12 months. 10 months at $300 is $3,000, and 2 more is $600. That is $3,600 a year, before insurance, fuel and repairs.
  6. Narrator: Its insurance is $1,800 a year, fuel is $900 and repairs are $300. $3,600 plus $1,800 is $5,400. Plus $900 is $6,300. Plus $300 is $6,600.
  7. Narrator: $6,600 minus $4,500 is $2,100. For this year, fixing the old car costs $2,100 less than replacing it.
  8. Marcus: But what if the old car keeps breaking?
  9. Narrator: Then the answer can change. If repairs reach $5,000 a year, keeping costs $5,000 plus $1,200 plus $1,200, which is $7,400. Replacing, at $6,600, now costs less.
  10. Narrator: Marcus also starts a car fund, money saved a little at a time for the next car or a big repair. $100 a month is $1,200 a year.

What you’ll learn

  1. What a car costs in a year

    A car costs more than its price. In a year you pay any loan payment, insurance, fuel and repairs. Insurance is money you pay a company so it pays for damage after a crash. Fuel is gas. All of it together is the total cost of ownership: every cost of having the car, not just the price.

    Old car: a $1,500 repair plus $600 of other repairs is $2,100. Add $1,200 for insurance and $1,200 for fuel. $2,100 plus $2,400 is $4,500 a year.

  2. Compare years, not payments

    A monthly payment looks small. Multiply it by 12 to see the year, then add insurance, fuel and repairs. Do this for fixing the old car and for replacing it. The lower yearly total costs less. If repair bills grow, keeping the old car can cost more.

    Replace: $300 a month is $3,600 a year. Plus $1,800 of insurance is $5,400. Plus $900 of fuel is $6,300. Plus $300 of repairs is $6,600. $6,600 minus $4,500 is $2,100.

  3. Lost value and owing too much

    Depreciation is the value a car loses as it gets older. You get no bill for it, but it shrinks what you can sell the car for. A loan balance is what you still owe. When the balance is more than the car is worth, you are underwater. Equity is the part of the car you truly own, so this is also called negative equity.

    A car is worth $6,000. The loan balance is $9,000. $9,000 minus $6,000 is $3,000. Selling the car still leaves $3,000 owed.

  4. A car fund and tax breaks

    A car fund is money you save each month for the next car or a big repair. Tax is money you pay the government. A tax break is a rule that lets you pay less tax. Tax breaks are set by law and can end, so check IRS.gov first. A break is not a reason to buy more car.

    A car fund of $100 a month is $1,200 a year. A break that saves $500 on a car that costs $3,000 more a year still leaves $2,500 more to pay.

Key words

total cost of ownership
every cost of having something, not just its price
depreciation
value a car loses as it gets older
underwater
owing more on a loan than the car is worth, also called negative equity
car fund
money saved a little at a time for the next car or a big repair

Common questions

What if I owe more than my car is worth?
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says a dealer or lender may offer to roll that balance into a new auto loan, but this makes the new loan more expensive. It is worth asking what the payoff is before you trade a car in.
Is there a tax break for buying a car?
The IRS says that for 2025 through 2028, some people can deduct interest on a loan for a new, personal car that had its final assembly in the United States, with a yearly cap and income limits. A deduction lowers the income that is taxed, so it saves only part of the interest. The New Clean Vehicle Credit ended for cars bought after September 30, 2025. Rules can change, so check IRS.gov.

Remember this

Compare yearly costs, not monthly payments.

Try it: Price a car for a full year

  1. Pick a car you own or might buy, and write its monthly payment, insurance, fuel and repairs.
  2. Multiply each monthly cost by 12, then add them for the yearly total.
  3. Start a Goal for a car fund, with a monthly amount you choose.

No account needed: write the four costs on paper, multiply each by 12 and add them. Try the Loan Payment Calculator for the payment.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Practice with real numbers:Check a car loan payment

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.