Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Benefit Cliffs: When a Raise Can Cost You

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: Some help shrinks or stops as you earn more. Check each program’s rules before a raise, and plan around the line.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: Some help shrinks or stops as you earn more. Check each program’s rules before a raise, and plan around the line.

The story: Dev gets a raise offer

Rosa and Dev sit at a kitchen table talking about a raise while a cart of food help and a warning sign appear.

  1. Narrator: Dev is offered a raise. Dev and Rosa are married with one child, and their household gets SNAP, a monthly amount to buy food.
  2. Rosa: A raise is good news. But will it change our SNAP?
  3. Narrator: Help like SNAP is made for households with less income, so it can shrink as income grows. When it shrinks a little for each extra dollar, that is a phase-out.
  4. Narrator: SNAP counts net income: income minus amounts SNAP allows, like part of housing costs. Each extra $100 of net income lowers SNAP by 30% of $100, which is $30.
  5. Narrator: For a family of three, the most SNAP pays is about $800 a month. At $1,200 of net income, 30% is $360, so SNAP is about $440.
  6. Narrator: At $1,300 of net income, 30% is $390, so SNAP is about $410. SNAP fell $30 while net income rose $100, so the household has $70 more.
  7. Narrator: A benefit cliff is different. At a benefit cliff, help stops all at once when income passes a line, so one more dollar can cost all of the help.
  8. Narrator: SNAP has a line like that too. In most cases, if gross income, all income before any deductions, passes the limit, SNAP stops.
  9. Dev: So before I say yes, we should check how each program counts income.
  10. Narrator: Yes. Ask each program how it counts income, and where the lines are. Then report changes on time.

What you’ll learn

  1. Help that depends on income

    A benefit is help a program gives you, like food money or health plan savings. Many are for households with less income. Each program counts income its own way. Countable income is the income a program uses to decide what help you get. It depends on household size too.

    SNAP counts net income: gross income, all income before deductions, minus the deductions SNAP allows. The Marketplace uses a tax number based on yearly pay before tax.

  2. A phase-out: help shrinks

    A phase-out is when a benefit gets smaller as countable income grows. SNAP works this way: take net monthly income times 0.3, which is 30%, and subtract it from the household’s top monthly amount. So each extra $100 lowers SNAP by $30, and the household keeps the other $70.

    For one person, the top amount is about $300. At $500 of net income, 30% is $150, so SNAP is $300 minus $150, or $150. At $600, 30% is $180, so SNAP is $120.

  3. A cliff: help stops

    A benefit cliff is when help ends all at once at an income line. Health plan savings through the Marketplace have an income range, and the top of that range has changed in some years, so check HealthCare.gov for the current one. Medicaid income levels differ from state to state.

    HealthCare.gov says savings are based on the income you estimate for the year you want coverage, not last year. Pia earned less last year but expects more now, so Pia uses the higher number.

  4. Plan before the raise

    Ask each program how it counts income. Report changes on time: HealthCare.gov says to tell the Marketplace right away. If more savings were paid ahead than you qualify for, you pay back the difference when you file federal taxes. Pay going into a retirement plan can also lower the income the Marketplace counts.

    HealthCare.gov says to start from gross pay and subtract what an employer takes out for child care, health coverage and retirement plans. So Kai’s pay into a retirement plan is subtracted.

Key words

benefit cliff
when help stops all at once at an income line
phase-out
when help shrinks a little for each extra dollar of income
countable income
the income a program uses to decide what help you get
benefit
help a program gives you, like food money or health plan savings

Common questions

Where can I get help paying for child care?
States get federal money to help families with low income pay for child care so they can work or go to school. Eligibility is different in each state, so check with your state.
Does the earned income tax credit have an income limit?
Yes. The IRS says you must meet certain adjusted gross income limits, and the amount of the credit is based on your income, filing status and number of qualifying children.
Can I apply for Medicaid any time?
Yes. HealthCare.gov says you can apply for Medicaid and CHIP any time of year. CHIP is the Children’s Health Insurance Program.

Remember this

Before a raise, check the cliffs, then plan around them.

Try it: Make a What-if with your raise

  1. Make a What-if with the raise you are thinking about.
  2. In its notes, list any help your household gets that counts income.
  3. Ask each program how it counts income and where its lines are.

No account needed: write today’s numbers and the raise numbers side by side on a sheet of paper.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.