Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free
Who to Trust With Money Advice
- Warm-up
- Story
- Learn
- Play
- Quiz
- Remember
- Try it
- Finish
About this lesson
About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions
The big idea: How a person gets paid shapes the advice they give. Even helpers who must act in your best interest can have conflicts, so ask how they are paid and check them with a free search.
Lesson outline
The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more
The big idea: How a person gets paid shapes the advice they give. Even helpers who must act in your best interest can have conflicts, so ask how they are paid and check them with a free search.
The story: Yara asks two helpers one question
Yara meets Reza, who sells funds for a commission, hears about a planner who charges by the hour, then checks both and asks how each is paid.
- Narrator: Yara has $5,000 saved and wants help investing it. Investing means putting money into things that can grow over time. Two helpers offer advice.
- Narrator: Reza is a broker, who buys and sells investments for people. A commission is a fee a broker earns each time you buy or sell. Reza earns one if Yara buys.
- Reza: This fund is a great choice. Put in the whole $5,000 today.
- Narrator: Say the fund pays Reza a commission of 5%. 5% of $5,000 is $250. Reza earns $250 only if Yara says yes.
- Yara: So Reza gets paid when I buy. Before I trust any advice, I want to ask how the helper is paid.
- Narrator: The other helper is a planner who charges $200 an hour and sells no investments. A planner paid only by fees like that is often called fee-only.
- Narrator: The law says Reza must act in Yara’s best interest when recommending a fund. Still, a commission can pull advice one way: a conflict of interest.
- Narrator: Yara looks up both on the free Investor.gov search. It shows if each is registered with the government, and any complaints or past trouble.
- Narrator: Then Yara asks each helper one plain question.
- Yara: A commission or a set fee can both be fair. I just want to know which one I am dealing with, and what it makes the helper want.
What you’ll learn
Pay shapes advice
Some helpers earn a commission, a fee paid each time you buy or sell an investment. Others charge a set fee. The way a helper is paid can pull advice toward one choice, which is a conflict of interest. A fiduciary is a person who must put your interest ahead of their own. Even so, ask: how are you paid?
A seller earns a 5% commission when you buy $1,000 of a fund. 5% of $1,000 is $50, and the seller gets it only if you buy.
Brokers, advisers and robo-advisers
A broker buys and sells investments for you, usually for a commission. An investment adviser gives ongoing advice, usually for a yearly fee that is a percent of your account. A robo-adviser is a computer program that does this online. Advisers must act in your best interest. Brokers must too when they recommend.
An adviser charges 1% a year on $2,000. 1% of $2,000 is $20, so the fee is $20 each year.
Planners and titles
A financial planner makes a plan for your money. Some charge a set or hourly fee and sell no investments, often called fee-only. Some earn commissions, and some get both. A title, like certified financial planner, comes from a group. Ask what it means and which group gave it, then check with that group.
A planner charges $150 an hour and spends 2 hours on your plan. 2 times $150 is $300, and nothing else is sold to you.
Finfluencers and checking
A finfluencer is a person who posts about money on social media, often to many followers. Some are paid to promote what they mention. Never decide from social media alone. Check anyone offering investments on the free search at Investor.gov, or on BrokerCheck from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority.
Key words
- fiduciary
- a person who must put your interest ahead of their own
- fee-only
- a planner paid only by a set or hourly fee, who sells no investments
- commission
- a fee a broker or seller earns each time you buy or sell
- finfluencer
- a person who posts about money on social media, often to many followers
Common questions
- Is Beth an advisor?
- No. Beth is Beyond Payday’s AI helper. Beth shares general information and helps you use the app. Beth is not a financial advisor and does not know your whole situation.
- Does a title like certified financial planner mean someone is a good adviser?
- Not by itself. The SEC, the federal agency that oversees investing, says titles are not all the same and a title does not always mean better service. Ask who issued it, then check with that group.
- Are brokers and advisers both required to act in my best interest?
- The SEC says investment advisers must, and brokers must when they make a recommendation. Both are still paid in ways that can create conflicts, so ask about them.
Remember this
Ask: how are you paid?
Try it: Look up a helper
- If you work with an adviser, look them up on BrokerCheck or the Investor.gov search.
- Write the question “How are you paid?” on your phone, so it is ready before a meeting.
- If someone online offers investment tips, check their background before you answer.
The whole mission; no account or app needed.
Live facts
Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.
Brokers: paid by commission; must act in your best interest when making a recommendation
Source: Investor.gov (SEC)(opens in a new tab)Investment advisers: required to act in your best interest; questions to ask, including how they are paid
Source: Investor.gov (SEC)(opens in a new tab)Check registration first; tricky titles
Source: Investor.gov (SEC)(opens in a new tab)Financial planners: fixed or hourly fees, commissions, or both; credentials
Source: Investor.gov (SEC)(opens in a new tab)What a robo-adviser is
Source: Investor.gov (SEC)(opens in a new tab)Social media and stock tip scams, including touting
Source: Investor.gov (SEC)(opens in a new tab)Finfluencers and how to check them
Source: FINRA(opens in a new tab)Look up a broker or adviser
Source: FINRA BrokerCheck(opens in a new tab)
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.