Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free
Rent or Buy: Is It Time?
- Warm-up
- Story
- Learn
- Play
- Quiz
- Remember
- Try it
- Finish
About this lesson
About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions
The big idea: Buying fits when you will stay several years, have savings beyond the down payment, and can pay the full monthly cost. Renting is not wasted money.
Lesson outline
The big idea: Buying fits when you will stay several years, have savings beyond the down payment, and can pay the full monthly cost. Renting is not wasted money.
The story: Piotr prices a home
Piotr compares the $1,500 rent of a home with the full monthly cost and the up-front cash of buying a $250,000 home, then decides to keep renting for now.
- Narrator: Piotr rents a home for $1,500 a month. Rent is the monthly price of a home you do not own. Now Piotr wonders about buying a home instead.
- Narrator: Most people buy with a mortgage, a home loan paid back each month. The lender is the bank or company that lends the money.
- Narrator: The lender will not lend the whole price. The buyer pays part in cash, up front. That cash is the down payment. Piotr looks at a $250,000 home.
- Narrator: Piotr plans 20% down. 10% of $250,000 is $25,000, so 20% is $50,000. The loan is the rest: $250,000 minus $50,000 is $200,000.
- Narrator: Interest is the price of borrowing. At 6% a year for 30 years, a loan calculator shows the $200,000 loan costs about $1,200 a month.
- Narrator: Owners pay more. Property tax, a yearly tax the town charges on a home, is about $250 a month. Home insurance, which pays for damage, is $100.
- Narrator: A homeowners association, or HOA, is a group that runs the neighborhood. It charges dues, a monthly fee, of $100. Piotr also saves $150 a month for repairs.
- Narrator: The total is $1,200 plus $250 plus $100 plus $100 plus $150, which is $1,800 a month. $1,800 minus the $1,500 rent is $300 more for owning.
- Narrator: Buying also takes cash up front: the $50,000 down payment, plus closing costs, the fees to finish buying, of $6,000. $50,000 plus $6,000 is $56,000.
- Narrator: Piotr might move in 2 years. Selling a home costs fees, taxes and pay for the agent who sells it. So for now, Piotr keeps renting and saving.
What you’ll learn
Two ways to pay for a home
Renting means paying a monthly price, called rent, for a home you do not own. Buying usually means a mortgage, a home loan paid back each month. A renter is free to move when the lease, the rental contract, ends. An owner pays for the home’s repairs, from small fixes to big replacements.
Nell rents for $800 a month. In many cases, the landlord, who owns the home, fixes a leaking sink. If Nell owned the home, Nell would pay the plumber.
What owning costs each month
The loan payment is only one part. It pays back principal, the money you borrowed, and interest, the price of borrowing. Add property taxes and home insurance. Add dues to a homeowners association, or HOA, the group that runs some neighborhoods. Add repairs and utilities, like power and water.
Ben’s loan payment is $1,000, taxes are $200, insurance is $80 and dues are $120. $1,000 plus $200 plus $80 plus $120 is $1,400 a month, before repairs.
Cash you need up front
The down payment is the part of the price you pay in cash. Closing costs are the fees to finish buying. You also need an emergency fund, cash set aside for surprises, because owners pay for their own repairs. Keep it whole after you pay to buy.
Kofi buys a $100,000 home with 10% down. 10% of $100,000 is $10,000. Closing costs are $3,000. $10,000 plus $3,000 is $13,000 in cash.
Equity, and how long you stay
Equity is what a home is worth minus what you still owe on the loan. Part of each payment pays down the loan, so equity can grow. Buying and selling cost fees, taxes and agent pay, so people stay long enough to cover them. The break-even year is the first year when buying has cost less in all than renting.
Sam’s home is worth $300,000, and Sam still owes $240,000 on the loan. $300,000 minus $240,000 is $60,000 of equity.
Key words
- down payment
- the part of a home’s price you pay in cash up front
- closing costs
- the fees to finish buying a home
- HOA
- a homeowners association, which charges the owners in a neighborhood or building monthly dues
- equity
- what a home is worth minus what you still owe on the loan
Common questions
- How do I know I am ready to buy?
- A common checklist: you expect to stay several years, you have savings beyond the down payment and closing costs, the full monthly cost leaves money to save, and your emergency fund stays whole.
- Why does the calculator need guesses?
- No one knows how home prices, rent or investments will change. The calculator asks for your guesses, so try a few different ones and see whether the answer holds.
- Can utilities cost more in a home I own?
- They can. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says an owner’s taxes, insurance, water and other utilities might cost more than a renter’s utilities, and that these costs are likely to increase over the course of a mortgage.
Remember this
Buying fits when the numbers and your plans both say stay.
Try it: Run the rent vs buy numbers
- Open the Rent vs Buy Calculator and type a rent, a home price and a down payment.
- Add the home’s taxes, insurance, dues and repairs, or keep the starting numbers.
- Change the number of years to compare, and note the break-even year.
Run the Rent vs Buy Calculator. No account is needed.
Live facts
Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.
A total monthly home payment includes mortgage principal, interest, property taxes, mortgage insurance, homeowner’s insurance, supplementary insurance and homeowners’ association fees; budget for home maintenance, repairs and utilities
Source: ConsumerFinance.gov (CFPB)(opens in a new tab)Buying and selling are expensive, so stay long enough to make these costs worth it; owners handle maintenance and repairs and need an emergency fund; taxes, insurance and utilities might cost more than renting and are likely to increase over the course of a mortgage
Source: ConsumerFinance.gov (CFPB)(opens in a new tab)Costs of a mortgage: principal, interest, closing costs, homeowners association dues
Source: ConsumerFinance.gov (CFPB)(opens in a new tab)What equity is
Source: ConsumerFinance.gov (CFPB)(opens in a new tab)Closing fees and charges
Source: ConsumerFinance.gov (CFPB)(opens in a new tab)
Builds on
Leads to
Practice with real numbers:Try the rent vs buy calculator
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.