Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Picking a Health Plan

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: The cheapest health plan is the one with the lowest yearly total for how you use care: premiums plus what you pay when you get care.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: The cheapest health plan is the one with the lowest yearly total for how you use care: premiums plus what you pay when you get care.

The story: Two plans, two kinds of year

In a clinic waiting room, Ana compares two health plan sheets on a balance scale while a friend, Marcus, talks about an unexpected ER visit.

  1. Narrator: Ana is picking a health plan at work. A health plan, also called health insurance, pays a big share of doctor and hospital bills.
  2. Narrator: The premium, the monthly price of the plan, is $50 for Plan A and $200 for Plan B. 12 times $50 is $600 a year. 12 times $200 is $2,400.
  3. Ana: Plan A is way cheaper. Easy choice.
  4. Marcus: That’s what I thought. Then I broke my ankle. I had to pay my whole deductible, the part you pay before the plan pays much at all.
  5. Narrator: Each plan also has an out-of-pocket max: the most you’d pay for care yourself in a year. It’s $6,500 on Plan A and $3,000 on Plan B.
  6. Narrator: In a quiet year with one $100 sick visit, Plan A costs $600 plus $100, or $700. Plan B costs $2,400 plus a $25 visit fee, or $2,425.
  7. Narrator: In a bad year with a $30,000 surgery, Ana pays up to the max. Plan A costs $600 plus $6,500, or $7,100. Plan B costs $2,400 plus $3,000, or $5,400.
  8. Ana: So the cheaper plan depends on the year I have. I also want my doctor in the plan’s network, the doctors it has deals with.

What you’ll learn

  1. How a health plan splits the bill

    A health plan pays a big share of your medical bills, so one bad year doesn’t empty your savings. You pay in two ways. The premium is the monthly price of the plan, paid whether you’re sick or well. When you get care, you also pay part of each bill.

    Plan A’s premium is $50 a month. 12 times $50 is $600 a year, paid even if you never see a doctor.

  2. Deductible, copay and coinsurance

    The deductible is what you pay before the plan shares the bill. Until you’ve paid that much, you pay the full price for most care. After that, you share. A copay is a set fee, like $25 a visit. Coinsurance is your percent of a bill, like 20%. Checkups from the plan’s doctors usually cost $0, even before the deductible.

    Say you’ve paid the deductible, and a bill is $300 with 20% coinsurance. 10% of $300 is $30, so 20% is $60. You pay $60, and the plan pays $240.

  3. Your worst case: the out-of-pocket max

    The out-of-pocket max is the most you pay in a plan year for covered care from the plan’s doctors. Once you reach it, the plan pays all of that care for the rest of the year. Add a year of premiums and you have your worst case. Doctors outside the plan, and care it doesn’t cover, don’t count toward it.

    Plan A’s worst case is $600 in premiums plus its $6,500 max. $600 plus $6,500 is $7,100.

  4. Compare yearly totals, and check the network

    Adding the costs for a quiet year and a bad year shows the real difference between plans. The network is the doctors, hospitals and drugstores a plan has deals with. Care outside it can cost far more, so people check that their doctors and medicines are covered before they pick.

    Plan A costs $700 in a quiet year and $7,100 in a bad one. Plan B costs $2,425 and $5,400.

Key words

copay
a set fee you pay for a visit or a medicine
coinsurance
your percent of a bill after the deductible
out-of-pocket maximum
the most you pay for covered care from the plan’s doctors in a year
network
the doctors, hospitals and drugstores a plan has deals with

Common questions

Is there a limit on how high the out-of-pocket max can go?
Yes. For most plans, the law sets a top limit, and it changes each year. HealthCare.gov lists this year’s number.
What if I buy my own plan instead of getting one through work?
The same math works. The Marketplace is HealthCare.gov or your state’s own site. Its plans list premiums, deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums the same way. Some people get help paying the premium based on income.

Remember this

Price a plan for a quiet year and a bad year, not just by its premium.

Try it: Test two plans on two kinds of year

  1. Pick two health plans you can choose from.
  2. Bad year: add a year of premiums to each plan’s out-of-pocket max.
  3. Quiet year: add a year of premiums to your usual care costs.
  4. Check that your doctors and medicines are covered.

Do the two-year math on paper with your real plans’ numbers.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.