Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free
Help Programs and the Benefit Cliff
- Warm-up
- Story
- Learn
- Play
- Quiz
- Remember
- Try it
- Finish
About this lesson
About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions
The big idea: Help programs shrink or stop as income rises, so a raise can leave some people with less in total. Count everything you gain and lose.
Lesson outline
The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more
The big idea: Help programs shrink or stop as income rises, so a raise can leave some people with less in total. Count everything you gain and lose.
The story: Ana gets a raise
Ana looks at a paystub and a help letter, then sees that a raise ends one kind of help and shrinks another.
- Narrator: Ana gets $1,900 a month after tax. Tax is money paid to the government, taken out of a paycheck before Ana gets it.
- Narrator: Ana also gets help from two programs. A help program is run by the government to help people pay for needs like food and child care.
- Narrator: Food help gives Ana $200 a month. Child care help pays $400 a month of Ana’s child care bill.
- Narrator: Pay after tax plus help is called total resources. $1,900 plus $200 plus $400 is $2,500.
- Ana: My boss gives me a raise, which is more pay for the same job. Now I get $2,100 after tax. That is $200 more.
- Narrator: Each program has an income limit, the most money coming in that a household can have and still get help. A household is the people who share a home and money.
- Narrator: Each program sets its own rules. The raise puts Ana just over the child care limit, so that help stops all at once. That is called a benefit cliff.
- Narrator: Ana’s food help works another way. It shrinks a little as pay goes up, which is called a phase-out. For Ana, the raise cuts it by $50, to $150.
- Narrator: Now add it up. $2,100 plus $150 plus $0 is $2,250. Before the raise it was $2,500. So the raise left Ana with $250 less in total.
- Ana: Next time I will ask my caseworker, the person at the help office who handles my case, what a raise would change.
What you’ll learn
What help programs are
A help program is run by the government to help people pay for needs like food, health care, heat and child care. Income is the money you earn. Most programs set an income limit, the most income a household can have and still get help. A household is the people who share a home and money.
A food program in Marcus’s state has an income limit of $2,000 a month. Marcus earns $1,500 a month. $1,500 is under $2,000, so Marcus may get help.
Two ways help changes
When pay goes up, help can change in two ways. In a phase-out, help shrinks a little for each extra dollar you earn. In a benefit cliff, help stops all at once when pay passes the income limit. Each program sets its own rules, so they differ.
Marcus gets $120 a month in food help. In Marcus’s program, it shrinks by $10 for each extra $100 earned. A $300 raise is 3 times $100, so help shrinks by $30, to $90.
Count your total resources
Pay after tax plus the help you receive is your total resources. A raise can look good by itself. But if it ends a help payment, your total can go down. So compare the total before and after, not just the pay.
Lee gets $1,200 after tax plus $500 in health help, so Lee’s total is $1,700. A raise to $1,400 ends the help. $1,400 plus $0 is $1,400, which is $300 less.
Plan around a cliff
Ask your caseworker, the person at the help office who handles your case, what a raise would change. Ask what each kind of help would be at the new pay. Tell the office about pay changes on time. For HealthCare.gov plans, reporting late can mean owing money back at tax time.
Nia’s pay goes up in March. Nia tells the help office that month and asks what changes, so the office can adjust the help right away.
Key words
- benefit cliff
- a sudden end to help when income passes a limit
- phase-out
- help that shrinks a little at a time as income rises
- total resources
- pay after tax plus the help you receive
- caseworker
- the person at a help office who handles your case
Common questions
- Does health help from HealthCare.gov have an income line?
- HealthCare.gov says savings are based on your income estimate for the year you want coverage. Whether savings stop above an income line can depend on the year’s rules, so check HealthCare.gov for this year. If your income changes, report it as soon as possible.
- How do I find out what I may qualify for?
- The benefit finder at usa.gov lets you pick categories like Food or Health and shows what you may qualify for. States set their own requirements for programs like SNAP and Medicaid, so check your state’s site too.
- What are the federal poverty guidelines?
- They are a yearly list of income levels. Some programs, such as SNAP, use them to check who qualifies. They are named for the year they are issued, so they change.
Remember this
Count everything you’d gain and lose, not just the raise.
Try it: Look up help that may fit
- Open the benefit finder at usa.gov and pick a category such as Food or Health.
- Look up your state’s income limit for one program that interests you.
- If you already get help, write down when each program wants pay changes reported.
Use the benefit finder at usa.gov and your state’s benefits website, outside this app.
Live facts
Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.
Marketplace savings: report income changes right away; late can mean owing money back at tax time
Source: HealthCare.gov(opens in a new tab)Premium tax credit depends on household size and estimated income; report changes to the Marketplace right away
Source: HealthCare.gov(opens in a new tab)Marketplace savings are based on this year’s income estimate; Medicaid and CHIP depend on income
Source: HealthCare.gov(opens in a new tab)SNAP helps pay for food with a low income; income limits and state requirements apply
Source: USA.gov(opens in a new tab)Medicaid insures people with a low income; each state has its own requirements
Source: USA.gov(opens in a new tab)Benefit finder: explore benefits available to you and how to apply
Source: USA.gov(opens in a new tab)Federal poverty guidelines are issued yearly and used by programs such as SNAP
Source: HHS ASPE(opens in a new tab)
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.