Skip to main content

Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free

Consolidate, Transfer or Refinance?

  1. Warm-up
  2. Story
  3. Learn
  4. Play
  5. Quiz
  6. Remember
  7. Try it
  8. Finish

About this lesson

About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions

The big idea: Moving a debt to a lower rate helps only if the fees are smaller than the savings and no new debt gets added. The test is the total cost before and after.

Lesson outline

The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more

The big idea: Moving a debt to a lower rate helps only if the fees are smaller than the savings and no new debt gets added. The test is the total cost before and after.

The story: Marcus looks at moving a debt

Marcus sits with a $2,000 credit card debt while a balance transfer and a consolidation loan are each compared with keeping the card.

  1. Narrator: Marcus owes $2,000 on a credit card, which lets you buy now and pay later. The card charges 25% a year, the yearly price of borrowing.
  2. Narrator: Interest is the price of borrowing that the card company charges. If the whole $2,000 stays owed for a year, 25% of $2,000 is $500 in interest.
  3. Marcus: I heard I can move this debt somewhere cheaper. Does that really save money?
  4. Narrator: One way is a balance transfer. A new card pays off the old card, so the debt moves. This new card charges 0% for 12 months, but a 5% fee.
  5. Narrator: The fee is a one-time charge for moving the debt. 5% of $2,000 is $100. So the first year costs $100 in fees plus $0 in interest, which is $100.
  6. Narrator: Keeping the old card costs $500. $500 minus $100 is $400 less. But after 12 months the low rate ends, and the next rate can be much higher, so check it first.
  7. Narrator: Another way is a consolidation loan: one new loan from a bank that pays off your debts, so you make one payment. Say it charges 10% a year.
  8. Narrator: The lender is the bank lending the money. A loan can have fees too. And a lower payment may only mean more months of interest. Compare the total cost.
  9. Marcus: So a lower rate is not enough. I will compare the fees and the interest first, and I will stop adding new purchases to the old card.

What you’ll learn

  1. Moving a debt

    A debt is money you owe. Your balance is how much you owe right now. To move a debt is to get a new card or loan that pays off the old one. To refinance is to replace a loan with a new loan, usually to get a lower rate. The rate is the yearly price of borrowing.

    A loan of $600 charges 10% a year. If the whole $600 stays owed for a year, the interest is 10% of $600, which is $60.

  2. Balance transfer: the fee and the end date

    A balance transfer moves your balance from one credit card to a new card, often one with a low or 0% rate for a set time. The card company can still charge a transfer fee, often a percent of the amount moved. When the low-rate time ends, the rate can rise a lot, so check it first.

    Sam moves $800 to a new card with a 5% fee. 10% of $800 is $80, so 5% is half of that, $40. Sam pays $40 before saving anything.

  3. Consolidation loans: check the term

    A consolidation loan is one new loan that pays off several debts. Compare its APR, the yearly rate with some fees counted in, and its term, the number of months to pay it back. A lower payment can come from a longer term, which can mean paying more in total. Some low rates last only a set time.

    Leaving out interest, $1,200 paid over 12 months is $100 a month. Over 24 months it is $50 a month, but the lender charges interest for twice as many months.

  4. Debt help: a plan or a settlement

    A credit counselor looks at your money and can set up a debt management plan, a payment schedule with you and the companies you owe. Debt settlement asks a company to take less than you owe. It might lower your credit score, the number lenders check, and the company can’t charge fees before it settles a debt.

    A company settles a $2,000 debt for $1,500, so $500 is canceled. That $500 may count as income you owe tax on, so the real saving is smaller.

Key words

balance transfer
a new card pays off the debt on an old card
consolidation loan
one new loan that pays off several debts
debt management plan
a payment schedule set up with a credit counselor
debt settlement
asking a company to take less than you owe

Common questions

What is a credit counselor?
A credit counselor is a person who looks at your money and helps make a plan. The Federal Trade Commission says a good one spends time with you and asks about your finances. A nonprofit label alone does not promise the help is free, affordable or real, and a real one does not charge in advance for help it has not given yet.
Do settlement programs tell you to stop paying?
The Federal Trade Commission says these programs often encourage you to stop making monthly payments to the companies you owe. It also says they might hurt your credit report and score.
Can a consolidation loan put my home at risk?
Some can. The Federal Trade Commission says some of these loans require you to put up your home as collateral, which means something you promise the lender can take if you do not pay. Ask before you sign.

Remember this

A lower rate only helps if the total goes down.

Try it: Compare the total before and after

  1. Pick one debt and write down its balance, its rate and its monthly payment, or use Rosa’s card from this lesson.
  2. Run it in the Loan Payoff Calculator with its current rate.
  3. Run it again with an offer’s rate and fees, then compare the two totals.

Use the Loan Payoff Calculator to compare your current rate with a real offer.

Live facts

Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.

Practice with real numbers:Try the loan payoff calculator

Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.