Learning as a guest. Your progress lasts until you close this tab. Save it free
Compare Job Offers by Total Pay
- Warm-up
- Story
- Learn
- Play
- Quiz
- Remember
- Try it
- Finish
About this lesson
About 15 minutes · 5 quiz questions
The big idea: A job’s real value is its total pay plus extras, minus what it costs you. It is not the salary alone, and an offer is worth what you keep.
Lesson outline
The whole lesson as text: the story, the ideas, key words and more
The big idea: A job’s real value is its total pay plus extras, minus what it costs you. It is not the salary alone, and an offer is worth what you keep.
The story: Ana weighs two offers
Ana sits at home with two job offers and a scale, adds the extras and subtracts the costs for each, and finds the lower salary leaves more.
- Narrator: Ana has two job offers. In an offer, an employer, a company that hires workers, says what job and pay it will give you. All numbers are before tax.
- Ana: Job A pays a salary, a set yearly pay, of $60,000, in a big city. Job B pays $50,000, in a smaller town. Job A looks better by $10,000.
- Narrator: But Ana counts the costs. In the big city, rent is $600 more each month. 10 months of $600 is $6,000, and 2 more is $1,200. That is $7,200 a year.
- Narrator: Job A’s commute, the trip to work, costs $200 a month. 12 months of $200 is $2,400. The health plan premium, its price, is $100 a month, so $1,200 a year.
- Narrator: Job A’s costs are $7,200 plus $2,400 plus $1,200, which is $10,800. $60,000 minus $10,800 leaves $49,200.
- Narrator: Job B has a match: money the employer adds when you save for retirement, the years after you stop working. If Ana saves 5% of the pay, the employer adds 5% too.
- Narrator: 10% of $50,000 is $5,000, so 5% is half, $2,500. Ana saves $2,500, and the employer adds $2,500 more.
- Narrator: Job B’s commute is $100 a month, so $1,200 a year. The health plan is $50 a month, and 12 months of $50 is $600. Rent stays the same.
- Narrator: Job B is $50,000 plus the $2,500 match, which is $52,500. The costs are $1,200 plus $600, which is $1,800. $52,500 minus $1,800 leaves $50,700.
- Ana: $50,700 minus $49,200 is $1,500. Job A pays $10,000 more, but Job B is worth $1,500 more to me. An offer is worth what you keep.
What you’ll learn
Add the extras
Total compensation is all the pay and perks a job gives you, not just the salary. A match is money the employer adds when you save for retirement. Paid time off is days you are paid while not working. Bonuses count too, and so does money the employer puts in a health savings account, an account for health costs.
Job B: $50,000 salary plus a 5% match. 10% of $50,000 is $5,000, so 5% is $2,500. Total pay is $52,500.
Subtract what the job costs you
Every job has costs. A commute, the trip to work, costs gas or a bus pass. A premium is the price you pay for the health plan, often taken from each paycheck. Cost of living is what everyday life costs in a place, and rent is often the biggest part. State taxes can differ from place to place too.
Job A: $60,000 minus $7,200 rent, $2,400 commute and $1,200 premium leaves $49,200.
Strings on a bonus
A signing bonus is money paid when you accept a job. Some come with a clawback, which means paying it back if you leave early. Each offer sets its own terms, so check how long you must stay and how much you would repay. Count a bonus only if you plan to stay long enough to keep it.
A $3,000 signing bonus says to repay it all if you leave in the first year. Leave after 8 months and you owe $3,000.
Growth, and getting it in writing
Training and room to grow count too, because they can raise your pay later. A written offer lists the pay, the start date, the health plan and the time off. A promise said out loud is hard to prove later, so ask to get it in writing.
A boss says you will get a raise in 6 months. Ask for those words in your offer letter, so you can point to them.
Key words
- total compensation
- all the pay and perks a job gives you, not just salary
- cost of living
- what everyday life costs in a place, often mostly rent
- signing bonus
- money paid when you accept a job, sometimes with a clawback: paying it back if you leave early
- paid time off
- days you are paid while not working
Common questions
- Does the law make employers give paid time off?
- Federal law does not require pay for time not worked, such as vacations, sick leave or holidays. Those are agreed between the employer and the worker, so they are worth asking about before you accept.
- Is the match really free money?
- It is money the employer adds to your retirement account, but you usually have to save too to get it. The IRS says employers can contribute to employees’ accounts. The plan’s rules say how much and when it is yours.
Remember this
An offer is worth what you keep, not what it says.
Try it: Compare two offers
- Write two offers side by side, real or dream, with the salary for each.
- Add the extras: match, paid time off, bonus and employer money for health costs.
- Subtract the costs: commute, health plan price and any extra rent.
- Run each offer through a take-home pay calculator to see tax, and compare what you keep.
Use the Take-Home Pay Calculator, once for each offer.
Live facts
Numbers that change over time, with when they were last checked and where they come from.
Employers can contribute to employees’ 401(k) accounts
Source: IRS, 401(k) plans(opens in a new tab)Employer contributions to an HSA are not included in income
Source: IRS, Publication 969(opens in a new tab)The FLSA does not require payment for time not worked, such as vacations, sick leave or holidays; these are matters of agreement
Source: U.S. Department of Labor, FLSA FAQ(opens in a new tab)
Builds on
Leads to
Practice with real numbers:Take-Home Pay Calculator
Lessons teach how money works. They are not financial advice.